Premium
This is an archive article published on August 17, 2010
Premium

Opinion Explain the silence

Despite the veil of satire,the author has unambiguously highlighted the chaotic nature of governance and the widespread confusion on almost all major issues of national concern....

The Indian Express

August 17, 2010 02:32 AM IST First published on: Aug 17, 2010 at 02:32 AM IST

This refers to Shekhar Gupta’s ‘Is anybody there?’ (IE,August 14). Despite the veil of satire,the author has unambiguously highlighted the chaotic nature of governance and the widespread confusion on almost all major issues of national concern — price rise,CWG,Bhopal,Kashmir. During the ‘90s,then-PM P.V. Narasimha Rao was often called “mauni baba” (saint of silence) for his lack of timely and judicious action. Today,the Union government is afflicted with internal criticism,dissensions and even back-stabbing,yet the PM prefers to maintain his silence,perhaps out of political exasperation. Does our leadership realise that its lack of responsibility,policy direction and vision will lead the country to chaos,particularly when insurgency and terrorism are gaining ground?

— Ved Guliani Chandigarh

Shekhar Gupta’s ‘Is anybody there?’ is timely. But the article also reminds me of the late Frank Moraes,who would pull no punches in his celebrated Monday column which I enjoyed from 1964 for as long as he wrote. Gupta’s criticism is well merited; in a sentence,Dr Singh seems to be very economical in communicating with the public. He is the PM of a vibrant democracy,noisy as it is,and to borrow John K. Galbraith’s words,“a functioning anarchy”. Very few are convinced that there’s a “trust deficit” with Pakistan,and so we must engage our neighbour in “dialogue”,whatever its brutal provocations. On prices and Maoists,the PM’s pronouncements sound empty. And the Congress president is even more remote when it comes to communicating. A Digvijay Singh or a Mani Shankar Aiyar gives the impression that they’re not amenable to discipline. Who’s there to reassure the public that there’s a responsive government at the Centre?

— P. Kanaka Durga

Bangalore

Words,not stones

Advertisement

n The Valley’s stone pelters must understand that nothing can be achieved by throwing stones at security personnel who are only doing their job. By doing so they are only alienating themselves. Confrontation is not a solution to Kashmir’s problems. The state cannot run away from its duty to maintain law and order. The PM has expressed his readiness to talk and help redress their grievances,and offered development and jobs. India as a secular democracy has many peaceful means of resolving pending issues.

— R.J. Khurana Bhopal

Fatal waste

When anywhere between 20 to 30 crore Indians sleep hungry every night,and over 7,000 die of hunger every day,wastage of foodgrains in FCI godowns is criminal. Do we need to talk about food security any more? On one hand,we are concerned about food security; on the other,we’re apathetic towards managing foodgrains. The food distribution systems are a shambles. It’s for the Union and state governments to rise to the occasion to properly procure,stock and distribute foodgrains without any wastage.

— Dilbag Rai

Chandigarh

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments