That Reality Punch

To reword a well-known phrase: those who live by the tube, die by it. And how. Last week, Uma Bharati chose to take a stand, in public, on T...

To reword a well-known phrase: those who live by the tube, die by it. And how. Last week, Uma Bharati chose to take a stand, in public, on TV, that too during a live broadcast of her party8217;s high command meeting. If it cut a sorry figure, the BJP has only itself to blame for courting publicity. On this occasion, those who had bloomed in the glare of TV lights, suddenly and visibly wilted before our astonished gazes: the entire top leadership, sat in silence, heads bent as the lady in saffron, scolded them. It was a memorable TV moment but one we8217;re sure, the BJP would rather forget.

Old habits die hard: if the Sangh Parivar is unable to stop flaunting its differences on air, CNN found itself embedded in Iraq, once again, as American troops advanced into Falluja. You8217;d think CNN might have resisted the temptation of accompanying the American forces, displayed more independence now that Iraq is, ostensibly, a free country. Instead, we were back in the spring of 2003 with CNN correspondent Jane Arrat smiling up at Lt Col Newell, girlishly: give us an idea of what is happening she asked 8212; a pretty dumb question, given that she8217;s been travelling with him and must have formed 8216;8216;an idea8217;8217; of what was 8216;8216;happening8217;8217;. He issued a very responsible statement on his troops8217; good intentions. Sounded rather like Father Christmas.

Switch to Al Jazeera, or its half-an-hour prime time bulletin carried by TV India. The camera angle tilts and you see the Arab side of the picture: a hospital overrun by troops, injured civilians, public appeals in Japan for the repatriation of its soldiers in Iraq 8212; every bit as partisan as CNN. Should you watch the news on the French TV5, it would, no doubt, present an entirely Gallic twist to the events. What about a South African or Chinese take, next?

If you were Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie what would you do on a farm? Pig it out? No, you8217;d wear a bikini, dark glasses and skinny-dip on the lawn just to remind yourself that you are Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie, not cow hands. Who are these women, anyway? The first sounds like a hotel on the Champs Elysee so of course she has to belong to the Hilton hotel family; the second is musician Lionel Richie8217;s daughter. And because they8217;ve haven8217;t an hour8217;s work between them, they charge off to heartland America to see what The Simple Life does to their make-up if they did some Star World.

They8217;re as out of place as you8217;d expect them to be. That8217;s the whole point: this reality show is all about our vicarious enjoyment of their increasing discomfiture. When Nicole groans, 8216;8216;I am so tired8217;8217; milking cows, you laugh, when Paris cries, 8216;8216;I have done more work in one day than in my entire life,8217;8217; you clap your hands, and when Nicole feels, 8216;8216;they8217;re treating us like animals8217;8217; while cleaning out the barns, you hoop with glee: serve them right for being ladies of leisure.

Obviously, they8217;re being paid a packet to slum it, yet this in no way diminishes the fun of hearing them bitch, watching them play pranks diluting the milk with water 8212; 8216;8216;it will be less fattening8217;8217; or behave like spoilt, rich brats 8216;8216;it stinks here8217;8217;, 8216;8216;I hate this8217;8217;, 8216;8216;it was terrible8217;8217;8230;.

There8217;s no greater pleasure in life than to watch other people be human and to err 8212; real flesh and blood people, not Friends like Monica or Joey; to see the contestants of The Apprentice stab each in the chest in order to cut each other out. It appeals to our baser instincts. Which is why Indian TV sees more reality shows: Sony8217;s Indian Idol, Zee8217;s Bollywood Dreams, MTV8217;s Roadies.

Story continues below this ad

Lastly, some fine performances, muscular arms to carry a camera, high energy levels and a hotel setting allowed CID to pull off its ambitious 111-minute-one-single-take episode Sony. Though why they wanted to produce it 8212; other than to prove they could 8212; is baffling since the usual 25-minute episode is normally entertaining enough.