Premium
This is an archive article published on December 14, 1999

Rules with a difference!

NEW DELHI, DEC 13: Manisha Malhotra lost a match she should have won in the $ 25,000 ITF women's circuit. At the DLTA complex on Monday, M...

.

NEW DELHI, DEC 13: Manisha Malhotra lost a match she should have won in the $ 25,000 ITF women’s circuit. At the DLTA complex on Monday, Manisha began well against her less-experienced rival Korean Eun-Young Ha is some 130 places below the India, won the first set untroubled, was serving for the match in the second before losing 6-4, 4-6, 6-7 (3-7) in 190 minutes.

Also ending up on the losing side was young Radhika Tulpule, whose match-up against Russian Anna Nefedova now reads 1-2. Nefedova won 7-6 (5), 2-6, 6-1.The one bright spot for India came late, when wild card Archana Venkataraman outlobbed and outsmarted Russian lucky loser Svetlana Mossiakova 2-6, 6-4, 6-4.

India No 1 Nirupama Vaidyanathan meets Arthi Venkataraman in another 1st round match on Tuesday, ensuring one Indian berth in the round of 16.One of the reasons Manisha’s match took so long was because of the lack of ball boys and the fact that both players, especially Korean Eun-Young Ha, took time to look despairingly at the chairumpire.

Story continues below this ad

The AITA said the decision to do away with ball boys and linesmen was the International Tennis Federation referee’s. Referee Hany El Khafeif said he “wanted to save the organisers the burden of costs and organising the ball boys etc.”

The ITF rules for $25,000 events state matters differently. Rule 8d says that two white badge umpires are needed for chair umpire. (This was followed). But also, one chair umpire and two linesmen are necessary upto the quarter-final stage in the main draw for all matches. And one umpire and four linesmen are a requirement for the semifinals and final. Rule 8e adds a minimum of three and a maximum of six ball boys or girls should be used up to the quarter-finals through the final.

The ITF referee also said, “You know, this is a girl’s event and girls are much easier and accomodating than boys. They also hit the ball less hard. Anyway, the standard here is not very high."

Anyway, with the referee’s blessings, the chair umpire could do no wrong. At one stage whenMalhotra hit the ball really long and it was called in. Ha protested. Only to be told that it was too far for the umpire to make out what was happening. If there is going to be only one officiating official, then if he’s good enough to sit in the chair, he should be good enough to see the court properly and make a decision.

Results

Story continues below this ad

Eun-Young Ha (Kor) bt Manisha Malhotra (Ind) 4-6, 6-4, 7-6 (7-3), Ju-Yeon Choi (Kor) bt 8-Katarina Daskovic (Yug) 6-2, 6-0, Anna Nefedova (Rus) bt Radhika Tulpule (Ind) 7-6 (5), 2-6, 6-1, Archana Venkataraman bt Svetlana Mossiakova (Rus) 2-6, 6-4, 6-4, Ka-Po Tong (HK) bt Victoria Davies (GB) 6-3, 7-6 (7-1).

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement