Premium
This is an archive article published on May 2, 2009
Premium

Opinion Eminent forebears

The Union law minister and the attorney general “stain” not only the government but also the system of democracy.

The Indian Express

May 2, 2009 12:59 AM IST First published on: May 2, 2009 at 12:59 AM IST

• The Union law minister and the attorney general “stain” not only the government but also the system of democracy. Here indeed is one attorney general who has made few appearances in court for the government in the last five years. The law minister of course was never credited with anything scintillatingly original for a lawyer. He would do well to find out how the man Nehru appointed as law minister,Ashoke K. Sen,conducted himself. There’s something else relevant to this context: when Richard Nixon was on the verge of impeachment,neither his attorney general,Elliot Richardson,nor Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox,the man appointed to examine the case,tried to help the beleaguered president vis-à-vis Watergate. They refused to abuse their positions or compromise their independence and personal integrity.

— M.K.D. Prasada Rao

Ghaziabad

Without a history

• The US Vice President Joe Biden has rightly said that Islamabad needs a “cultural change” to view that “India is not its enemy”. Virtually every Indian policy-maker,scholar and Pakistan watcher has echoed the same sentiments. Since the birth of Pakistan,events have repeatedly proved that while a stable and powerful Pakistan is a constant challenge to India’s security,an unstable and weak Pakistan is even more dangerous.

Advertisement

Since Independence,India has remained the main reference point for Pakistan. What international observers don’t understand is that Pakistan doesn’t have a history to fall back on. Therefore,its elite — civilian and military — must propagate a permanent threat from India to retain its grip on power.

— Mathew Oommen

Pune

Undignified stooges

• The editorial ‘The two stooges’ convincingly conveys the indignity of being stooges and rubber stamps on the attorney general and the law minister in letting Ottavio Quattrocchi off the hook. However,shouldn’t you have gone so far as to publicly name all those guilty,all those who help the Congress go about its business of “institution wrecking”?

— M. Ratan

New Delhi

Salvaging the CBI

• The Indian Express must be congratulated for exposing the professional incompetence of the CBI again. There’s little doubt that the CBI was misused by the Congress-led UPA government for political and extra-political reasons. The UPA’s tenure will be remembered for the new lows the credibility of our institutions and agencies touched. Whoever comes to power later this month must categorically de-link the CBI from politics.

— Manoj Parashar

Greater Noida

Protect them

Advertisement

• The death of Bharat Borge leaves us clueless about the twists and turns of the Anil Ambani helicopter “sabotage” case. But India’s record on witness protection is dismal. That doesn’t help a country affected by corruption of every kind as well as terrorism. We have lost many political leaders and prominent citizens to conspiracies. It’s time whistleblowers and witnesses were given sound protection.

— C.K. Subramaniam

Sanpada

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments