Premium
This is an archive article published on October 8, 2009
Premium

Opinion To what end?

Apropos Jaithirth Rao’s article,I want to make sure I understand. The unique ID project is a plan that does not actually have a purpose?

The Indian Express

October 8, 2009 03:14 AM IST First published on: Oct 8, 2009 at 03:14 AM IST

• Apropos Jaithirth Rao’s article,I want to make sure I understand. The unique ID project is a plan that does not actually have a purpose? It has technological goals,which — when achieved — will be technological feats. (Trust me,he says,and I do!) But for the rest of it? The MHA,the MEA or whatever wants it,the babus and those politicos,let them work it out?

Personally,I have applied for and received gas,telephones,a car,educational degrees,a driving licence,a PAN card,a voter’s ID card and a passport without needing to prove that I,the applicant,myself exist. I am banging down doors,shoving in queues,shouting through little windows,and the government has so far recognised this without a problem as proof that I exist. What the government asks for is proof that I live where I say I live,proof that I am Indian,proof that I am as old as I say I am.

Advertisement

The unique ID will link across many systems,we are told,even all the systems that man hasn’t yet imagined,but the fact is that the many private and public sector systems of India have never before needed proof of being,the only thing it seems this project can provide. If I haven’t understood anything,however,or my imagination is dry,then Rao must write another article. Supply,sir,a point about the final purpose of this project. Is it only that it will free us from photocopy attestation?

— Shruti Debi

New Delhi

HRD initiatives

• Human resource development vis-à-vis migration is important,and needs to be seen in the right intellectual perspective. As a matter of serious concern,affecting the country’s development,everybody should be responsible and involved,not just the minister in charge. India should benefit from focus on human resource as a phase of development. Brain drain should be stopped; this is a developed form of managing human resources,which should be deployed for further progress of the country. But instead of formal work discipline,a more hearty initiative is needed from everybody.

— Rathin K. Chanda

Chinsurah

Scary scuffle

• Your editorial ‘Altitude sickness’ rightly observes that whosoever may be held responsible for what happened aboard the Air India Sharjah-Delhi flight — 30,000 feet above sea level — the fact will remain that human lives were endangered. It was something unprecedented and extremely shocking. One shudders to think of the passengers on board. It is Air India’s callousness towards passenger safety that a pilot with a history of bad behaviour continued to fly. More than others,a pilot is responsible for the flight’s and passengers’ safety. The pilot must be given exemplary punishment.

— M.C. Joshi

Lucknow

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments