Premium
This is an archive article published on September 11, 2005

Tuesday146;s Child

DID the spectacular terrorist attacks in New York and Washington four years ago change the world forever? While scholars will continue to de...

.

DID the spectacular terrorist attacks in New York and Washington four years ago change the world forever? While scholars will continue to debate this question for a long time, there is little doubt that the global consequences of 9/11 fundamentally altered India8217;s own security condition.

Whether it was India8217;s longstanding war on terrorism or the relations with the United States and Pakistan, 9/11 produced lasting changes in India8217;s neighbourhood.

Less than two months before 9/11, in July 2001, the failed Agra summit between Atal Behari Vajpayee and Pervez Musharraf reflected the huge gap between the immense aspirations for peace in the subcontinent and the huge obstacles in moving towards that objective.

At Agra, Vajpayee and Musharraf vainly tried to overcome the legacy of the Kargil war of 1999. The simmering tensions between India and Pakistan did not take long to boil over again, when terrorists launched a dramatic attack on Parliament on December 13, 2001.

Forced to respond vigorously, India launched the biggest military mobilisation in its history, with the demand that Pakistan cease terrorism once and for all. As New Delhi and Islamabad teetered on the brink of war, the Anglo-American powers intervened.

Because of that intervention, Musharraf promised in January 2002 that he would not support terrorism in the name of Kashmir. Musharraf, who in Agra contemptuously rejected the very idea of cross-border terrorism, was now moving a little forward under Anglo-American pressure.

With India refusing to relent and a renewed military crisis in May following new terrorist attacks in Kashmir, Musharraf promised the Bush administration he would end infiltration on permanent basis. This promise defused the Indo-Pakistani military confrontation.

Story continues below this ad

The Anglo-American intervention, led by the Bush administration, also radically restructured the triangular relationship between India, Pakistan and the United States

The DC-Delhi duet

9/11 as a publishing event
Bush at War
8226;
Bob Woodward
Veteran journalist draws on diverse sources in the US administration to give an inside account of the Bush war team8217;s military response.
Against all Enemies: Inside America8217;s War on Terror
8226; Richard Clarke A former adviser to George W. Bush critiques his foreign policy.
Ghost Wars
8226; Steve Coll
A Washington Post editor airs the CIA8217;s dirty linen in the back story to 9/11.
9/11 Commission Report
Anerica8217;s National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States shows how the first draft of history could be written.
Who Killed Daniel Pearl?
8226; Bernard-Henri Levy
French philosopher investigates an American jouralist8217;s death in Karachi and finds some collateral damage of 9/11.
Saturday
8226; Ian McEwan
A novel of uncommon brilliance connects the good citizen and the terrorist challenge.
Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
8226; Jonathan Safran Foer
An eccentric nine-year-old comes to terms with his father8217;s death that fateful day.
Muniya8217;s Light: A Narrative of Truth and Myth
8226; Ramachandra Gandhi
Confused young adult deals with 9/11 questions through an introduction to philosophy.
The Plot Against America
8226; Philip Roth
Novelist wrestles with history amidst post-9/11 what-ifs.
In the Shadow of No Towers
8226; Art Spiegelman
A graphic novelist8217;s breathtaking depiction of the days after.
Mini Kapoor

ON September 11, India naturally assumed the biggest terrorist attack ever would open the door for the long-awaited partnership with the US, especially in India8217;s own war on terror since the mid-1980s. That President George W. Bush was well disposed towards India and was committed to elevating Indo-US ties to a strategic level was widely signalled by senior American officials.

Unlike his predecessors, Bush refused to see India through the traditional prism of Pakistan and South Asia, and wanted to treat India as an emerging global power.

It was on this basis that India immediately offered all possible assistance to the US, including the use of its military facilities for action against the obnoxious Taliban regime that so humiliated India during the hijack of IC-814 in the final days of 1999.

Story continues below this ad

Despite India8217;s extraordinary offer of support, it was Pakistan that the United States turned to. The logic of geography and the deep knowledge of the Pakistani military establishment about Afghanistan meant Islamabad was at the frontlines of the American war on terror.

The resumption of economic and military assistance to Pakistan cast a huge shadow over Indo-US relations. New Delhi feared renewed American cooperation with Pakistan would be at India8217;s expense.

TO its credit, the Bush administration was determined to prevent a return of the traditional zero sum game. While reaching out to Pakistan, it also sustained pressure on Islamabad to end its terrorist operations against India and ensured the ambitious agenda of bilateral cooperation with New Delhi remained intact.

Besides getting Pakistan to commit itself to ending infiltration, the Bush administration publicly declared support for the elections to the Jammu and Kashmir assembly in 2002.

Story continues below this ad

Besides removing India8217;s longstanding suspicions about American intentions in Kashmir, the Bush administration transformed the former contentious debate on nuclear issues into a cooperative one.

The Next Steps in Strategic Partnership announced in the first Bush term were followed by historic nuclear pact early in the second term, in July 2005. A few days earlier, in June 2005, India and the US signed a 10-year framework agreement for defence cooperation.

For the first time in nearly six decades, Indo-US relations have begun to look expansive. The framework for the strategic partnership that eluded Delhi and Washington in the aftermath of 9/11 has now begun to fall in place.

Detoxifying Pakistan
THE new American agenda in Pakistan was not without a historic irony. It was the need to push the Soviet Red Army out of Afghanistan in the 1980s that resulted in the joint US-Pakistan promotion of a jihad against godless communists. This eventually resulted in the Taliban and Osama bin Ladin.

As the wheel turned full circle on 9/11, the very forces of religious extremism and violence instrumentalised by Washington turned against the US. As a shaken America took on these forces, the burden of cleaning up the mess now fell upon the very institution that nurtured them 8212; the Pakistani army.

Story continues below this ad

Confronted with the choice posed by the Bush administration 8212; 8216;8216;With us or against us8217;8217; 8212; Musharraf chose, however reluctantly, to offer cooperation to the US in ousting the Taliban and hunting bin ladin and Al Qaeda.

The9/11 Legacy
Four years, four collateral gains
8226;
The Taliban is history. India regains its clout in Afghanistan
8226; India8217;s war on terror is subsumed under the global war on jihad. Musharraf is now America8217;s problem
8226; Recognising India as the stable nation in the region, the US reaches out to it
8226; Pakistan puts forward a moderate face, on Kashmir, extremism and, overall, in terms of bilateral ties

In doing so, Musharraf hoped to protect his Kashmir policy, political investments in Afghanistan, as well as his nuclear weapons from American pressure. But on all the three, he had to make significant adjustments.

THE revelation of A.Q. Khan8217;s nuclear smuggling racket forced Pakistan to take steps towards curbing the kind of cavalier nuclear exports it had pursued since the late 1980s. While the US recognised the basic interests of Pakistan in Afghanistan as a neighbour, it was unwilling to give a veto to Islamabad on Kabul.

The US also maintained relentless pressure on Musharraf to root out Al Qaeda-Taliban from the Pak-Afghan borderlands. The US decision to establish a strategic partnership with Afghanistan dispelled any misconceptions in Islamabad that the American attention to Afghanistan would be shortlived.

Story continues below this ad

On Kashmir, the American pressure on Musharraf to end infiltration and dismantle the terror infrastructure, while not entirely satisfactory to India, did begin to produce some results and created conditions for a credible peace process between India and Pakistan.

Peace, in our time
THE steps taken by Musharraf in relation to terrorism since 2002 8212; inconceivable without 9/11 and American nudging 8212; gave the political space for India to begin substantive negotiations with Pakistan.

Overcoming the persistent questions on whether India could trust Musharraf, Vajpayee extended the hand of friendship once again in April 2003. The quiet contact between the two sides resulted in a new framework for peace talks in January 2004.

The change of government in India in May 2004 did not affect the peace process, as Prime Minister Manmohan Singh took to it in an equally vigorous manner. More positive developments have occurred in Indo-Pakistani relations, especially in Kashmir, in the past one year than in five previous decades.

Story continues below this ad

In April 2005 Singh and Musharraf declared the peace process irreversible. They also came up with a broad set of propositions, such as making borders in Kashmir irrelevant, to define the new engagement.

Meeting again in New York this week Singh and Musharraf are expected to give a further boost to the peace process.

A new subcontinent
THE single biggest outcome of 9/11 has been the ouster of the Taliban regime. The routing of the Taliban allowed India to regain its influence in Afghanistan. If the rule of the previous military dictator, Zia-ul-Haq, produced a jihad in Afghanistan and promoted Islamic regression inside Pakistan, the Musharraf years will be remembered for a renewed effort to promote Islamic moderation and economic modernisation.

While Musharraf cannot yet claim complete success, his internal reforms and the peace process with India should have a longterm positive impact on Hindu-Muslim relations across the subcontinent, and undermine the forces of communalism and religious extremism.

Story continues below this ad

The events of 9/11 also generated greater international interest and involvement in other conflicts of the subcontinent. The focus on terrorism, forced the Tamil Tigers in Sri Lanka to come back to the negotiating table. Thanks to 9/11, there is greater consultation and cooperation among India, the US, UK and the European Union in dealing with the Maoist challenge in Nepal, and the growth of extremism in Bangladesh.

While the region is a long way from a resolution of these conflicts, the external circumstances, especially the absence of great power rivalry, have never been as conducive for greater international and regional cooperation to promote peace and prosperity in the subcontinent.

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Loading Taboola...
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement