
Historians were in for some bashing on the inaugural day of the 66th annual session of the Indian History Congress today, with its new president-elect, S N Jha, targeting the 8216;8216;stereotyping of Hinduism as a monolithic, tolerant religion8217;8217;.
While Lok Sabha Speaker Somnath Chatterjee and Union Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee voiced concern over using 8216;8216;political power8217;8217; to settle historical debates, Jha went all out against the 8216;8216;scholars of religion8217;8217; and 8216;8216;communal forces that have brought a cultural chauvinism8217;8217; in historical writings.
Addressing delegates, from Pakistan, Nepal, UK and Bangaldesh, Speaker Somnath Chatterjee said historians are at times perceived as the 8216;8216;monopoly suppliers of the past8217;8217;.
8216;8216;But the past sometimes happens to be distorted past,8217;8217; he added. The Speaker added that those who propagate the theory that Hindus and Muslims cannot live together should remember that the national anthem of Bangladesh was written by Rabindranath Tagore.
He warned against confusing 8216;8216;mythology8217;8217; with historical fact and using 8216;8216;political power to settle historical debates8217;8217;. Chatterjee also expressed his desire to have an 8216;8216;objective8217;8217; history of Parliament written for posterity.
Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee, while asserting that 8216;8216;mythology cannot be considered science8217;8217;, said writings in history should be objective and dispassionate. 8216;8216;If that does not happen, historians will lose their esteem before the public,8217;8217; he said.