Premium
This is an archive article published on August 3, 2011
Premium

Opinion The new racism,same as the old

Hatred of Muslims in Europe and the United States is a growing political industry.

August 3, 2011 12:09 AM IST First published on: Aug 3, 2011 at 12:09 AM IST

Soon after I was born my father moved our family from Britain back to his native South Africa to become dean of the school for black medical students at the University of the Witwatersrand. Blacks were obliged to live separately from whites,a principal reason for his having left Johannesburg in the first place.

He told the students he was handing them responsibility for their affairs; that helped settle things on campus. Outside was a different story. Much of my father’s time was spent going to police stations to negotiate the release of black students who had been detained for no reason by stupid white cops. Once he arrived to hear an Afrikaner policeman scoffing at a young black woman who was close to qualification as a doctor: “You think you’re some clever student,but really you’re just a Kaffir.” (The insult is now legally actionable in South Africa.)

Advertisement

Racism is stupidity’s recourse. There are plenty of stupid people in the world. Apartheid survived for almost a half-century,a system based on the view that the only thing blacks were good for was to work as hewers of wood and drawers of water. After my father returned with the family to England,we’d go back regularly to South Africa. I remember the jacarandas,the faraway horizons,the firm yellow peaches. Beauty was abundant,but a shadow lurked. That’s how I absorbed racism,like a twinge,the first hint of a dangerous microbe in your blood.

These things shape you. The Jews in South Africa tended to view the blacks as a large buffer against their own persecution,even as they were more engaged than most in trying to break the system. It’s a grotesque thought,but if you’re busy persecuting tens of millions of blacks you don’t have much time left over for tens of thousands of Jews. This thought did occur to the Jews,whose families (many of Lithuanian origin),had fled European pogroms and so avoided the ditches to which Hitler’s Einsatzgruppen would have dispatched them. As a South African Jew,watching blacks without passes being bundled into the back of police vans was discomfiting. But this was not mass murder after all. You tried to look away.

Racism is a mind game. It makes its victims grateful for small mercies until such time as they rise in uncontainable anger.

Advertisement

I was schooled early by South Africa in racism’s poison. I wondered at the blacks swimming in a filthy harbour when whites-only sand stretched for miles. I caught the illicit glances as an adolescent,flirtation as crime. I listened to the meat-chomping justifications,bigotry dressed up as scientific theory.

Over in England things were OK. I got called a “yid” for a while at school,and looked up Jew in the Oxford English Dictionary of the day. “Definition 1: A person of Hebrew descent; a person whose religion is Judaism. Definition 2: A person who behaves in a manner formerly attributed to Jews; a grasping or extortionate person.” There you go.

Nothing makes my blood boil like racism. I got a lot of angry mail over a recent column about Norway’s rightist mass murderer and his sympathy with “racist Islamophobia.” Muslims are not a race,the writers claimed. Funny,several of the angry notes were from Jews,who seemed to have forgotten that not being a race but a religion had scarcely saved Jews from racist persecution: Perhaps the Einsatzgruppen just got in a semantic muddle before opening fire. Perhaps the Malaysian soccer crowd who just booed Chelsea’s Yossi Benayoun,an Israeli player and a Jew,were not really racists. Dream on.

Hatred of Muslims in Europe and the United States is a growing political industry. It’s odious,dangerous and racist. Thanks to my New York Times colleague Andrea Elliott,we now know the story of the orchestration of the successful anti-Sharia campaign in the United States,led by a Hasidic Jew named David Yerushalmi who holds that “most of the fundamental differences between the races are genetic.” The rightists in Europe using anti-Muslim rhetoric are true heirs to the Continent’s darkest hours.

I’m glad that at an impressionable age my Dad told me of a dumb white cop with power telling a smart young black woman with promise she was “really just a Kaffir.” The settings change,the vile stupidity does not.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments