Premium
This is an archive article published on January 10, 2010

Not all vegetarians are healthy

A lot of people turn vegetarian for a variety of reasons. Some do so for weight control,as they associate meat intake with weight gain.

A lot of people turn vegetarian for a variety of reasons. Some do so for weight control,as they associate meat intake with weight gain. Some have religious reasons,others start feeling strongly about cruelty to animals while some take the spiritual angle—believing that if one wants to live in peace and happiness,then one can’t eat meat,fish,fowl or eggs.

But is vegetarianism healthy? Several studies show that regular fruit and vegetable consumption reduces the risk of coronary artery disease. A recent survey of 47,000 Italians found that persons with the highest vegetable consumption had a 21 per cent reduced risk of heart attacks compared to those with the lowest vegetable consumption. Vegetarians also appear to have lower blood pressure and lower rates of hypertension and Type 2 diabetes than non-vegetarians. In one study,it was noted that the risk of most cancers was 20 to 50 per cent lower for those with a high consumption of whole grains as compared to those with a low consumption. Vegetarians also tend to have a lower body mass index and lower overall cancer rates.

The longest living populations in the world have very little meat in their diets and largely eat whole grains,fruits and vegetables. A vegetarian diet is also definitely rich in antioxidants and phytochemicals.
Despite the benefits of vegetarian diets,vegetarians and vegans (those who also avoid animal derivatives such as milk and dairy) are at risk of several nutritional deficiencies like those of vitamin B12,iron and calcium. Meat,eggs,and dairy are good sources of these nutrients. Vitamin B12 is almost exclusively found in animal food. Iron is especially a concern for vegetarian women in the reproductive age,who are at risk of deficiency due to menstrual losses. Iron and vitamin B12 are essential for formation of red blood cells,maintenance of good haemoglobin levels and proper functioning of the central nervous system.

Story continues below this ad

Women are also at higher risk than men for developing osteoporosis especially if their calcium needs aren’t met. Even though iron and calcium requirements can be met in vegetarian diets,the bio-availability of these nutrients from vegetarian sources is not comparable to that from non-vegetarian sources.
Who is a vegetarian or a non-vegetarian in the Indian context? Most Indian vegetarians pile on the five Ps—potatoes,paneer,paranthas,puris and pulses. They hardly have any vegetable and fruit intake,let alone eating brightly-coloured or dark green vegetables,nuts and other protective foods. They don’t fully reap the benefits of a veggie diet,thanks to a high intake of polyunsaturated fat (present in refined oils) and saturated fats (present in vanaspati). They also consume a lot of dairy and milk owing to their “no-meat status”.

A complete opposite is the Western counterpart who is typically a converted health-conscious vegetarian,and includes whole grains,legumes,fresh fruits and vegetables,plenty of nuts,seeds,soya and good fat in his diet. In other words,a vegetarian diet can be more unhealthy than a non-vegetarian one. A lot depends on what you really eat rather than simply being vegetarian or otherwise.

Mediterranean diet forms an ideal example of a healthy non-vegetarian diet. It comprises high-carbohydrate foods including bread,pasta,rice,couscous and polenta; fruits,vegetables,nuts,seeds and legumes; olive oil; and dairy foods such as cheese and yoghurt; fish,poultry,eggs and sweets are consumed in moderation whereas red meat is consumed occasionally.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement