
The chemists8217; strike ended as surprisingly as it began on Tuesday. But even in its end there are some grey areas as to how it ended and who lost 8211; BMC or the chemists. Just a day8217;s notice was given before all pharmacies, including those located in hospitals, downed their shutters protesting against BMC8217;s decision to levy two per cent octroi on medicines. The stir ended just as abruptly on Thursday, a few hours after a delegation of striking chemists walked out of Mayor Nandu Satam8217;s chamber at BMC headquarters convinced they would have to continue the bandh. But finally, all that the three-day bandh yielded was just promises. Assurances from two politicians not connected in any way with BMC 8211; BJP city unit president Kirit Somaiya and Shiv Sena leader Uddhav Thackeray 8211; that the matter would be considered sympathetically.
Now, reports suggest that the chemists8217; associations have been asked to submit proposals regarding city8217;s development, perhaps as a quid pro quo for waiving octroi. Does that meanthat BMC, which had so far resisted every attempt to switch octroi with an account-based cess, is now ready to replace it with charity. Octroi, the world has learnt, is an outdated mode of collection of tax. It involves huge infrastructural costs and entails unending queues at octroi nakas, not to mention the endemic corruption. Among the 187 member countries of the United Nations, only India and Ethiopia have this system. Every other country has deviced simpler, much cheaper methods of collecting this tax. Even in India quite a few states have found an alternative. Rajasthan has introduced a surcharge on sales tax and Gujarat too is considering a similar method. Even neighbouring Navi Mumbai has experimented, and with considerable success, with an account-based cess. The chemists8217; strike has presented BMC with an opportunity to change 8211; a change for better.