Premium
This is an archive article published on December 29, 2006

Our trouble with boys

I watch my son struggle to process many mixed messages about men and what they are capable of

.

The poignant images of five murdered women that dominated the front pages last week presented me with the usual task of explaining the issues arising from such news to my 12-year-old son. It8217;s never easy to do so, but at least the idea that women are simply immoral for taking to the profession is beginning to lose its grip as statistics show that the majority are drug dependent and vulnerable.

However, a matching awareness that men caught in this world may also be vulnerable has not arisen, which still presented me with difficulties in explanation. Men who use prostitutes are only ever portrayed as misogynist, criminal and, worst of all, macho. Macho is worst because it suggests that the abuse of women is somehow natural to men8230;As my son struggles to process the many mixed messages about men and what they are capable of, I feel compelled to play up his feminine side. But is that the best way to help him engage with his masculinity as he enters puberty?8230;

Since the 80s we have engaged with feminism privately and publicly. In schools this has translated into a sort of gender neutrality 8212; an emphasis on equality of opportunity rather than on the diversity of needs. Without question this is 8220;fair8221; and hence 8220;right8221;. But as girls tend to be more mature than boys the same age, in co-educational schools this results in the creation of norms that are more female than male.

What is understood to be deviant behaviour, for example, is almost without exception boys8217; behaviour. The way that girls can be destructive in more emotionally adroit ways, is not acknowledged by detentions. At a very early age, this can result in boys pathologising their own gender, withdrawing from girls 8212; and school 8212; and gathering in groups of their own kind8230;

It8217;s time for the gender debate to become a dialogue. When men are alienated from the discourse on male behaviour they are more likely to suppress its extremes than own them and the chance for transformation is gone.

Excerpted from a piece by Indra Adnan, in 8216;The Guardian8217;, December 28

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement