Premium
This is an archive article published on August 9, 2005

Constitution Bench for Bihar House dissolution

The Public Interest Litigation challenging the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly will now be heard by a Constitution Bench. A three-judge be...

.

The Public Interest Litigation challenging the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly will now be heard by a Constitution Bench.

A three-judge bench of Chief Justice R.C. Lahoti and Justices C.K. Thakker and P.K. Balasubramanyam today decided to refer the matter to a Constitution Bench after the petitioners—two MLAs of the dissolved House—and the Centre agreed that the issue involved questions on the powers of the Governor, which required a Constitution Bench.

The petition will come up for hearing before the Constitution Bench on September 6. The court also kept open the option of referring it to an even larger bench reminding the Attorney-General that such a move would require forceful arguments from his side.

Story continues below this ad

On July 25, the apex court, while perusing the PIL had allowed one of the petitioners Poornima Yadav, an Independent MLA in the dissolved House, to move an application for interim orders. The decision was significant as it amounted to keeping open the possibility of even the restoration of the dissolved Assembly.

Yadav’s counsel had told the court that under the S.R. Bommai case ruling, ‘‘the least relief’’ was ‘‘an injunction restraining the holding of fresh elections’’. The bench brushed aside the contention of the Government that the interim relief envisaged by the Bommai verdict could not be applied to Bihar where the Assembly was dissolved without being constituted.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement