Premium
This is an archive article published on March 23, 2007

A reel life question

Marines love it. Iran calls it an act of war. 300 is essentially a Spartan (yet lavish) videogame, but people take it seriously.

.

Marines love it. Iran calls it an act of war. 300 is essentially a Spartan (yet lavish) videogame, but people take it seriously.

The New York Times and the government of Iran agree: The movie 300 has no redeeming social value. The movie, which depicts the brave stand of 300 Spartans against a marauding army of hundreds of thousands of Persians at Thermopylae in 480 BC, “is about as violent as ‘Apocalypto’ and twice as stupid,” according to A.O. Scott, the Times’ movie critic. The Iranians, who presumably don’t screen many Mel Gibson movies, were nonetheless even more offended. The movie is aimed at “humiliating” Iranians, who are descendants of the ancient Persians, said Javad Shamghardi, cultural adviser to Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad: 300 is “part of a comprehensive US psychological warfare aimed at Iranian culture.” And this was the headline in the Ayan No newspaper: Hollywood declares war on Iranians.

To most moviegoers, 300 may or may not evoke the Clash of Civilisations, but it certainly is popular among young American men. The R-rated film grossed more than $70 million its opening weekend, the biggest March debut ever. The majority of the audience was under 25 (though there were a surprising number of older viewers). They were probably not drawn by their interest in classical Greece. The bloody 2004 epics Troy and Alexander were expensive box-office duds; 300 was made for $65 million in a warehouse in Montreal, using B-list actors filmed against a blue screen, with the digital mayhem painted in. Aggressively marketed online, 300 may be none too cerebral, but it is disturbingly beautiful. It looks and feels like a lavish slash-and-chop videogame.

Story continues below this ad

Still, the cultural significance and popular appeal of 300 reach beyond the thrill of watching pixilated decapitations. The Persians in 300 are the forces of evil: Dark-skinned, depraved and determined to terrorise the West. The noble, light-skinned Spartans possess a fierce love of liberty, not to mention fierce six-pack abs. “Freedom is not free,” says the wife of Spartan King Leonidas. The movie was adapted from a graphic novel by Frank Miller (Sin City). Miller’s post-9/11 conservatism (he is reportedly working on a new graphic novel pitting Batman against al Qaeda, titled Holy Terror, Batman!) suffuses his comic-book fantasies. Perhaps it’s no surprise, then, that 300 resonates for some real warriors. At a theater near Camp Pendleton outside San Diego, cheers erupted at a showing of 300, the Los

Angeles Times reported.

The analogy between the war on terror and the death struggle of ancient Greece with Persia has not been lost on some high administration officials either, especially Vice President Dick Cheney. (A White House spokesman declined to comment about the film.) In the months after 9/11, a classics scholar named Victor Davis Hanson wrote a series of powerful pieces for the National Review Online, later collected and published as a book, An Autumn of War. Moved by Hanson’s evocative essays, Cheney invited Hanson to dine with him and talk about the wars the Greeks waged against the Asian hordes, in defence of justice and reason, two and a half millennia ago.

The movie is a cartoon, based very loosely on historical fact. The Persians are depicted as either effeminate or vicious abusers of women, while the Greeks are manly men. The bad guys in 300 also include corrupt Spartan politicians who refuse to send more troops to the battle. Some right-wing bloggers have likened them to liberal Democrats voting against the surge in Iraq. Moviegoers may be a little confused by other cultural echoes in the film. The Spartan heroes seem to be in love with what one of them calls “a beautiful death.” Just like, er, Islamic suicide bombers.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement