Premium
This is an archive article published on March 18, 2016
Premium

Opinion Hand of the bully

Congress must take responsibility for its role in the disgraceful suspension from the Maharashtra assembly of Waris Pathan.

Waris Pathan, Owaisi, bharat mata ki jai, AIMIM, Asaduddin Owaisi, Bharat Mata ki Jai, Maharasthra Assembly, AIMIM MLA suspended, Hail India slogan, Assembly suspends AIMIM MLA
March 18, 2016 12:00 AM IST First published on: Mar 18, 2016 at 12:00 AM IST
Waris Pathan, Owaisi, bharat mata ki jai, AIMIM, Asaduddin Owaisi, Bharat Mata ki Jai, Maharasthra Assembly, AIMIM MLA suspended, Hail India slogan, Assembly suspends AIMIM MLA Waris Pathan

Everyone must be patriotic, and patriotism will be defined by the bully, by those who can shout the loudest, have their way. You will be tested on not just the slogans you raise but also on those that you do not. Patriotism will be force-fed by the BJP and its parivar, but not just by them. If you are deemed to be not patriotic enough, be very afraid, also, of the Congress… These are a few of the lessons, it seems, that must be drawn from the unprecedented and shameful proceedings in the Maharashtra assembly, which suspended an elected AIMIM legislator, Waris Pathan, for the remaining part of the current budget session for not saying “Bharat Mata ki Jai” on Wednesday. The resolution moved by Minister of State for Home Ranjit Patil, disapproving of Pathan’s conduct and summarily punishing him for it, was backed by the NCP, BJP, Shiv Sena and the Congress. The Congress played a leading role in the arbitrary banishment of Pathan, who was pronounced guilty and given no hearing, even as the speaker went by the “feeling” of the House, not its laid-out procedures and rules.

[related-post]

Of course, the Congress may have political reasons to be resentful of the AIMIM. Asaduddin Owaisi’s party is only a small outfit from Hyderabad, but its audacity and ambition have unsettled traditional claimants of the “Muslim vote”. The MIM’s foray in Bihar did not amount to much electorally, but the campaign in which the Congress labelled Owaisi’s party as a BJP-RSS stooge out to divide the “secular” vote has left a bitter after-taste. The Congress must know, however, that it cannot let its political gripe against Owaisi spill over into an outrage like the one in the Maharashtra assembly on Wednesday. It would do well to listen to what its own leader said in the Lok Sabha a few days ago. Party vice president Rahul Gandhi warned the government against attempts to raise the flag to silence and to intimidate: “Respecting the flag means respecting the opinion of every Indian… You cannot defend the Indian flag by destroying the relationships between our people”. His words had struck a chord in a political climate in which Kashmiri students on a university campus in Rajasthan must face the mob and be arrested because of rumours that they were cooking beef, even as two JNU students still languish in jail for participating in a campus event to commemorate the hanging of Afzal Guru where “anti-national” slogans were raised.

Advertisement

Congressmen may choose not to pay attention to Rahul Gandhi, but can Rahul Gandhi afford not to be mindful of his own words in Parliament? If he wants to be taken seriously, he must take note of his partymen’s role in the suspension of Pathan and hold them to account. There are many guilty men in the disgraceful episode in the Maharashtra assembly and the Congress cannot escape the blame.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments