Opinion In Paris,its yesterday once more
Frances presidential candidates and electorate are seeking solace in the past to avoid looking to the future
Frances presidential candidates and electorate are seeking solace in the past to avoid looking to the future
OLIVIER GUEZ
From the subject of halal meat to the matter of drivers licences,the French presidential campaign has been marked by peripheral squabbles and endless invective among the candidates. But few things have been said about the gravity of the French economic crisis: the deficits in Frances public accounts and balance of payments; its drop in competitiveness; its decline in international commerce; its apathetic growth.
Nor have we heard much about the threat of increased unemployment and reduced purchasing power from the austerity measures that the markets expect any president to take. As for civil war in Syria,the perilous transitions in Arab countries,al-Qaedas progress in the Sahel,or Irans nuclear programme,the candidates have behaved as if nothing were the matter as if France were tacitly abandoning all influence abroad.
These omissions say a great deal about the state of a country that has rarely seemed so avid in its navel-gazing,so inward-looking. France in 2012 is an old nation that increasingly cultivates the temptation to be an island unto itself.
So many examples from these last few years come to mind: magazine covers devoted to President Nicolas Sarkozy almost every week; the January 7 issue of Le Figaro,naming Joan of Arc Woman of the Year. Indeed,the French dont like the 21st century,and would gladly give it back. Their desire has its roots in a confluence of failures (the defeat in 1940 and the loss of their colonial empire) and the rejection,by other European nations,of building a Europe à la fraknçaise France on a bigger scale. France has become a middling power,with a mass culture and a society of consumption like everyone else. Gaullism and communism kept up the illusion that a great history,a great destiny were still Frances to be had. It didnt pan out that way. So as the world heeds France less,the French long to shut themselves off from it,to turn towards olden days and protect themselves.
The electoral campaign flattered their aspirations. The populist candidates outdid themselves with magic formulas to get France out of history as fast as possible. Marine Le Pen,the favourite of young voters,promised the moon and the stars if France left the eurozone,limited employment and social benefits to French citizens and finally drove all foreigners out. Jean-Luc Mélenchon,that great orator,rekindled the spirit of revolutionary mythology by summoning Robespierre,Fidel Castro,Jean Jaurès,Hugo Chávez and Victor Hugo,while throwing to the wolves the bosses,the bourgeois,the journalists,Wall Street and the CAC 40 index on the Paris bourse. The major contending parties President Sarkozys centre-right Union for a Popular Movement and François Hollandes Socialists did not rush the French people. The tears and blood Sarkozy promised them soon gave way to generous promises and the appointment of other scapegoats poorly patrolled frontiers,fiscal exiles,free trade,the European Central Bank,clandestine immigrants. Meanwhile,Hollande made do with waiting for a change in power,avoiding faux pas,reassuring his fellow countrymen by aping,as best he could,the virtuoso he claimed to follow: François Mitterrand.
But all 10 candidates had one enemy in common: globalisation,that perpetual movement of capital,people and merchandise that endangers the French social model cherished by 90 per cent of French people even as it threatens to definitively bring them to ruin. Among all inhabitants of developed nations,it seems,none hate globalisation more than the French. All their political leaders have promised to fight against it. But no one fights globalisation alone. No one can lie down alone in the path of history with impunity. While candidates promise brighter tomorrows,convinced that the worst of the crisis has passed, markets watch their every move; their European partners (and toughest competitors) pursue reforms even as emerging nations continue to grow at dizzying rates.
In 1981,France rejected the path being set by Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher. Mitterrand and his Socialists,with their communist allies,embarked on a grand programme of nationalisation. Two years later,isolated,Mitterrand and his France had to turn abruptly toward austerity. It will be much the same in 2012: whatever the new president will have promised before the election,reality will intrude. France will wake up to austerity again.
The writer is a French journalist