Who will keep the trust?

It is not often that a political happening in the capital is transformed into a national drama with a spectacular finale. But if live televi...

It is not often that a political happening in the capital is transformed into a national drama with a spectacular finale. But if live television coverage transformed the two-day debate on the vote of confidence into a happening in which every Indian was an active participant, the credit has to go to Atal Bihari Vajpayee. Using his formidable oratorial skills to the hilt, Vajpayee successfully transformed the dubious reputation of presiding over India8217;s most short-lived government into a political achievement. As he wound up the debate with the dramatic announcement of his resignation, he was not merely achieving political martyrdom. He was elevating himself to the role of a folk hero. For a politician in a country where the people have learnt to be deeply suspicious of those in public life, this was a stupendous feat. Vajpayee always possessed charm; after Tuesday8217;s debate, he has acquired charisma, albeit that of a tragic hero. In the battle for the hearts and minds of the electorate, Vajpayee has emerged triumphant.

From an editorial in 8216;The Indian Express8217;, May 29, 1996

One thing is certain in these uncertain days. There will be more of the two-day-long debates that precede votes of confidence or no-confidence in Parliament. So, judging by what has gone before, the country should steel itself for more rambling speeches, interminable interruptions, light asides and the other things that pass for a serious debate. In terms of time and money, it is an expensive way for MPs to say what has been said already or is irrelevant. Televised hearings were supposed to be an aid to participatory democracy, bringing about wider awareness among the people about crucial parliamentary processes, especially those involving the rise and fall of governments. Few would have thought when Doordarshan brought the proceedings live to every home that there would be so much tedium and so much cause for exasperation. Audience ratings, for sure, are at rock bottom. For MPs and political parties it is a great opportunity lost.

From an editorial in 8216;The Indian Express8217;, April 19, 1999