Breathless Sania-Shoaib coverage was predictable; that of Naxal violence was surprisingly nuanced
While India TV was showing us a pair of clothes which,according to them,could prove that Shoaib Malik was with Ayesha Siddiqui six years ago,on Tuesday night NDTVs Prannoy Roy displayed the red corridor where blood has been running water in the battle between the security forces and the Naxals. The distance between the two events pretty much covers the road travelled by the news in the last few days.
We witnessed a seamless transition from the personal scandal of Pakistani cricketer Shoaib Malik,in Hyderabad for his marriage to tennis player Sania Mirza,to the national horror of 75-odd CRPF men being killed in Chhattisgarh. That we went from one to the other without more than a Breaking News separating them,that they were treated with the same degree of seriousness (Times Nows 9 pm talkathon went from the Maoists to Malik-Mirza) says everything you ever wanted to know about the news: it doesnt discriminate,its the great equaliser.
Previously,news channels positively delighted in close ups of the dead. But although we saw injured CRPF personnel in hospital and bodies lying in an inert row,news channels spared us the gory details. Also,the coverage delved deeper than the headlines of the immediate massacre: While channels like Times Now and NDTV clearly took sides as Arnab Goswami said,against the Naxals,they also questioned the government and the home secretary,critically. They revealed difficulties Operation Green Hunt faced in its attempts to eliminate the Maoists Headlines Today accompanied a CRPF unit in Dantewada on a fruitless operation. NDTV interviewed ordinary inhabitants of the villages combed by the CRPF. People described how security forces had brutalised them. CNN-IBN reported on NGOs and activists in the north east being rounded up for anti-national activities because they opposed development efforts such as the construction of dams.
Thus,beyond the rhetoric of discussions,TV news managed to convey a complex,multi-dimensional issue that just wont go away.
India TVs garment investigation provided the Shoaib Malik-Ayesha Siddiqui controversy with a new dimension,too. Since the proposed Malik-Mirza was revealed last week,weve seen more of Shoaib than we ever did on the cricket field. Weve seen little of Ayesha S,barring her photographs with or without Shoaib,but weve heard her story till we could recite it. That the story has become an Indo-Pak affair,involving two established sportspersons,that there seemed to be more to it than met then eye,lent it a piquancy irresistible to the media on both sides of the Wagah border.
The centrepiece of the coverage was Sania Mirza and Shoaib Akhtar holding forth (or should it be court?) at an open-air news conference on Monday. It followed a weekend of the Shoaib and Ayesha show with her allegations that he was married to her. What a tangled triangle. Sania Mirza tried to pin the media to the baseline with her verbal volleys,flushed and angry. An aggressive,suspicious bunch of journalists pounced on her and Shoaibs every statement. For someone who has been a media darling till now,it must have been a harrowing experience for Sania.
Thereafter,news channels were abuzz with speculation that their wedding may not take place. By Tuesday,the will-they-wont-they marry saga was reported as a favourite on the satta bazaar. The media was clearly enjoying itself and Sanias plea to let the law take its course did not inhibit them: they continued to pursue the couple and the story.
This was a kind of Tiger Woods moment for Shoaib that was rubbing off on Mirza. Is that fair? No,of course not. But the relentless media coverage seems to have forced Shoaib and Sania (odd they have the same first and second name initials) to answer questions publicly. It may have also contributed to Shoaibs divorcing Ayesha,as reported on Wednesday,for all his earlier protestations. Some of the coverage may have not looked good but this isnt a beauty contest. It is the television news business where everything is fair game,set and match.


