Trawl through the 24 pages of the Common Minimum Programme, and a fascinating game begins. It is called Trace the Thumbprint of the Left. It...
3 min read
Whatsapp
Twitter
Facebook
Reddit
Trawl through the 24 pages of the Common Minimum Programme, and a fascinating game begins. It is called Trace the Thumbprint of the Left. It is there in the section on labour. It is there in the reference to 8220;traditional ties with West Asia8221;. It is evident, also, in its warning to those 8220;who try to deliberately engineer market panic8221;. Let8217;s face it. In the UPA8217;s agenda for governance, there is an invisible hand. And it poses a big challenge to India8217;s new order. Adam Smith8217;s hidden forelimb, the market, has over the decades been kept in some semblance of check, all sorts of regulatory mechanisms are in place to temper its distortions and its volatility. Who will, alas, hold the Left8217;s invisible hand in documents and decisions of the Manmohan Singh government?
The Left parties say they broadly endorse the CMP. Not being in government, however, they have refrained from affixing their signatures to the document. Moreover, they reserve the right to differ with economic policies pursued by the UPA coalition. Talk about a dialectical mess! When it comes to the art of running coalitions, the Left parties are given to raptures of self-laudation. They point happily to decades of uninterrupted rule in West Bengal, they talk of a periodic return to proletariat rule in Kerala. They have a point. Why, then, do they toss aside decades of accumulated wisdom whenever they come within shouting range of Raisina Hill?
You’ve Read Your Free Stories For Now
Sign up and keep reading more stories that matter to you.
They must decide once and for all whether they are part of the Manmohan Singh government or not. If they are not, if they are insistent on supporting the UPA from the outside, they must limit their interventions to critiques and appreciations from the outside. For their leaders to hold up copies of the UPA8217;s Common Minimum Programme in a pretty photo-op is to highlight the dual game being played. The CMP is not a vision document, it is an articulation of the agenda and goals a coalition commits itself to. It provides a list of objectives, on the delivery of which a voter can decide whether the coalition has acted upon its promises. That delivery can only be made by those who are in government, those who have taken the responsibility to govern. The Left parties have not. Therefore there can be little justification for them to wield the power to dictate the coalition8217;s agenda.