
The Union government has approached the Central Bureau of Investigation CBI again, under pressure from Left parties, for a probe into the sale of Centaur hotels. This, even though the CBI had returned the file last week after it found that a probe was not possible on the basis of the evidence in the CAG report. The Left parties, it seems, will not be satisfied with anything less than a CBI probe and the UPA government 8212; pretty desperate to satisfy its political allies 8212; has now been driven to hand over the entire disinvestment file to the CBI, demanding that it embark upon an investigation.
In its earlier communication to the CBI, the Union finance ministry is reported to have ruled out any mala fide factors in the sale of the hotel to the single bidder, or in fixing the reserve price. The allegation of mala fide lies in the belief that merely because there was a single bidder for the hotel, there must have been something wrong. However, the decision to sell the hotel to a single bidder was taken by the Cabinet Committee on Disinvestment and it does not suggest that any one person 8212; the disinvestment minister, members of the PMO or any other person 8212; was responsible for the deal. There is now an attempt to raise questions as to why did the other bidders opted out. It can only be hoped that the government does not now choose to harass those who had decided to opt out, because this will certainly send out a wrong signal on the government8217;s disinvestment process, and could even dissuade people from bidding for anything related to the government 8212; today it may be the sale of a hotel, tomorrow it may well be the construction of a road 8212; in the future.
Since the CBI has not found enough evidence to pursue the case, it would have been far more sensible on the part of the government to have informed its Left allies that the matter is now closed. Flogging a dead horse in this manner is a futile 8212; and damaging 8212; business.