‘Absolutely correct but misconstrued’: CPM backs Speaker Shamseer over Ganesh remark

While inaugurating an education project in the Kunnathunad Assembly constituency in Ernakulam on July 21, Shamseer said that myths should not be promoted as science, citing pushpaka vimana and the birth of Kauravas.

“Plastic surgery is a new invention in medical science. But what is being taught is that plastic surgery had existed in ancient times… The example was Ganapati, with a man’s body and an elephant’s face. Instead of science, such myths are being promoted,’’ he purportedly said.

Over the past one week, the BJP has been mounting an attack on Shamseer, a prominent young Muslim face of the CPM. The controversy assumed a new dimension on Tuesday, when the Nair Service Society, an influential outfit of the upper-caste Nair community, alleged hatred for Hindus behind the remark.

The NSS is observing Wednesday as “faith protection day” and has urged its members to turn up at Ganapati temples to make special offerings to mark the day.

Govindan said there was an electoral agenda behind the controversy. “There is a bid to divide society over the speaker’s speech. It was Prime Minister Narendra Modi who stated that Ganapati was born out of plastic surgery. Congress leader Sashi Tharoor also said Modi’s statement on Ganapati was wrong. No one should encroach on science on behalf of myths and one cannot move ahead by rejecting science,’’ he said.

Govindan said the party believes that science should be seen as science, history as history and myth as myth. “The party is always for the democratic rights of the atheists as well as theists. The RSS’s attempt is to make myths a part of history. They are adding Ganapati and pushpaka vimanam to the pages of history. At the same time, they take the stand that the assassination of Gandhi, the Mughal period and Charles Darwin’ theory of evolution should not be taught,” he said.

Attacking Congress leaders who have sought an apology from the Speaker, Govindan said that Nehru was a rationalist. “Congress leaders should read Nehru before repeating the arguments of the BJP and Sangh Parivar,” he said.

The Congress demanded on Wednesday that the Speaker correct his statement as it would otherwise serve as ammunition for communal forces.

Opposition Leader V D Satheesan said the Congress’s view is that scientific temper should not be mixed with religious faith. “Neither the government nor the judiciary should intervene in religious faith and rituals. The CPM wants to divide society over the Speaker’s remark and reap political dividends,” he said.