This is an archive article published on April 6, 2009
Skeletons out
It's one of the most controversial game shows in television history. Moment of Truth has been accused of many things promoting voyeurism,breaking up marriages and even ruining lives.
Are we Indians ready to tell all in the desi version of Moment of Truth?
It’s one of the most controversial game shows in television history. Moment of Truth has been accused of many things promoting voyeurism,breaking up marriages and even ruining lives. But that doesnt mean it isnt successful so successful,in fact,that an Indian version is soon to hit our screens. But the big question is; will a show that expects participants to reveal their most intimate secrets on primetime television work in India?
Why not? asks trade analyst Taran Adarsh,Indian television is growing by leaps and bounds and so are the sensibilities of the Indian viewers. Reality shows are catching up in India in a big way and there is no reason why this show shouldnt do well. The reality factor will keep them hooked,because unlike other shows,there wont
necessarily be any happy endings here. The unpredictability of this show will work in its favour.
The whole premise of the show is based on getting people to answer truthfully to extremely personal questions about themselves. The veracity of the answers is determined by a polygraph,popularly known as a lie detector. The show starts out with relatively mild questions about cheating on exams and gets progressively tougher as participants are asked extremely personal questions about their marriage and their relationship with their family and friends. Viewer Gautam Pal,whos an avid fan of the American original,says the whole pleasure can be summed up as schadenfreude taking delight in the suffering of others. Its sadistic,I know,but its a very basic human instinct. Its the same vicarious thrill we get from watching girls bitching at each other on MTV Splitsvilla. Here,you put yourself in the contestants place and try and imagine how youll fool the polygraph.
Psychotherapist Seema Hingorrany says that the show will definitely find viewers,but she cites different reasons for it. People love to watch other people spilling their secrets in public. Theres a sadistic thrill.
But while there will be an audience,theres no saying if there will be enough contestants for the show. Were not a very open society. Indian women particularly find it very difficult to let out intimate details of their lives.
Story continues below this ad
But Siddhartha Basu,whose Big Synergy is producing the show,is optimistic. Weve already shot the pilot episode and the feedback on that has been positive. As for doubts about whether people will open up before the camera,I can assure you that Indians have no qualms about being honest about themselves. We already have many volunteers to participate on the show both celebrity and non-celebrity. As for any backlash on its controversial content,Basu says that theyve already taken precautions. Our intention is not to hurt anyone. Our contestants have the option of leaving the show before it gets too uncomfortable or of changing their answers from the ones they gave to the polygraph machine. But we make sure that our contestants fully understand the implication of their participation and we sign an agreement with them in that regard.
Pooja Pillai is a Senior Assistant Editor at The Indian Express, working with the National Editorial and Opinion section. Her work frequently explores the intersection of society, culture and technology.
Editorial Focus & Expertise
Pooja’s writing spans several key domains, often blending analytical commentary with cultural critique.
Art & Culture: She writes extensively on cinema, books, and the evolving landscape of arts and entertainment.
Technology & Society: Her work examines the human impact of the gig economy, the rise of AI in creative fields, and the cultural shifts driven by digital platforms.
Food & Lifestyle: She often uses food as a lens to explore history and politics, covering everything from the origins of pantry essentials to the impact of nutrition policy.
Politics: She closely tracks political developments in South and West India and provides commentary on international political transitions, including the shifting landscape of American politics.
Multimedia & Podcasting
Pooja is a prominent voice in the Indian Express’s digital ecosystem. She is the host of 'DeshKaal with Yogendra Yadav', weekly video podcast where she facilitates deep-dive conversations on Indian democracy, social movements, and current political affairs.
Notable Recent Works
Cinema & Identity: “SRK@60: Why Shah Rukh Khan is Bollywood's last, and only, superstar” – an analysis of stardom and the changing face of Indian identity
Global Politics: Commentary on the Trump administration’s misguided “war on woke culture” via typography and analysis of the visual semiotics of Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s attire during successive visits to the White House.
Art & AI: “An unequal music: AI is lowering barriers at the cost of music itself” – a critique of how technology is redefining artistic value.
Professional Presence
Pooja is active on X (formerly Twitter) and Instagram, where she shares her latest columns and editorial insights.
Her full archive and latest updates can be found on her Indian Express Author Profile. ... Read More