Montek cheer for Bharti,Vodafone

Mobile phone operators who looked resigned to spending over Rs 1 lakh crore if they were to win back their 900 MHz spectrum when it was refarmed

Mobile phone operators who looked resigned to spending over Rs 1 lakh crore if they were to win back their 900 MHz spectrum when it was refarmed have got a new lease of life with Planning Commission deputy chairman Montek Singh Ahluwalia suggesting the issue needed a more thorough analysis. Apart from this,BSNL and MTNL could end up paying around Rs 35,000 crore if they wish to retain their 900 MHz spectrum,assuming the base price of this is kept at twice that of the 1800 MHz spectrum as suggested by Trai.

In a letter on Tuesday to members of the inter-ministerial panel which has to take a final call on the matter,Singh wrote,I had indicated during the discussion that we need a more thorough analysis of the issues involved,keeping in mind the need to minimise disruption.

Ahluwalia said contrary to the view that the issue had been discussed adequately with the industry,the Trai 2012 report did indicate that consultations have been held with the stakeholders However,the stakeholders8230; preponderantly requested that refarming of spectrum may be part of a separate consultation process on grounds of equity,competition and potential disruption of mobile services on this account.

He said,I am also informed that the Telecom Commission has never considered a detailed paper with full information indicating what is the best methodology for refarming,especially given the international experience so far. The matter was most recently discussed in the telecom commission meeting held on October 15. However,as pointed out by the secretary,Planning Commission,to the EGoM,all that the Telecom Commission did was consider the three alternatives partial,full and zero refarming.

Ahluwalia said there was no analysis of the pros and cons. According to estimates,if the telecom industry surrendered its 900 MHz spectrum and took 1800 MHz spectrum,it would mean reworking entire networks. Cost estimates of this range from Rs 1 lakh crore to Rs 1.5 lakh crore. FE