Premium
This is an archive article published on May 29, 1999

Plea challenging Sonia8217;s right to become PM withdrawn

MUMBAI, MAY 28: The Bombay High Court today allowed two Bharatiya Janata Party BJP leaders to withdraw their public interest litigation...

.

MUMBAI, MAY 28: The Bombay High Court today allowed two Bharatiya Janata Party BJP leaders to withdraw their public interest litigation PIL which questioned All India Congress Committee president Sonia Gandhi8217;s legal eligibility to become prime minister under the Indian Constitution, she being of foreign origin.

Vacation judge D K Deshmukh allowed withdrawal of the petition with liberty to file again after petitioner8217;s counsel R V Bhasin said his clients were doing so in view of the existing political scenario and also because they wanted to amend the petition.

The petition, filed by Mangalprabhat Lodha, BJP Member of the Legislative Assembly in Maharashtra, and Vishal Vinod Sharma, general secretary of the BJP Yuva Morcha, sought the court8217;s interpretation on articles of the Constitution which define political rights of foreign-born persons who take up citizenship here after marrying Indians.

It was argued that a foreign-born woman was not covered under Article 1 of the Constitution and hence, shewas also not covered under Article 15, which banned discrimination on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.

Besides, it said, the overall reading of the Constitution eliminated aliens8217; from being covered to hold the office of a minister or prime minister. The petitioners submitted that the expression place of birth8217; stated in Article 15 could only mean a place of birth within India and not outside India.

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement