Premium
This is an archive article published on April 10, 2005

Pages from prison

If any journalist secretly nourishes a wish of being thrown into jail for the sake of a good narrative, Iftikhar Gilani8217;s soon-to-be-re...

.

If any journalist secretly nourishes a wish of being thrown into jail for the sake of a good narrative, Iftikhar Gilani8217;s soon-to-be-released My days in Prison Penguin, Rs 195 should discourage him.

For, not only has Gilani exposed the suseptibility of a scribe in being targetted with trumped-up charges in his case, under the antiquited Official Secrets Act, he has also revealed the extent to which the Government8217;s intelligence agencies can stoop to make the charges stick.

In Gilani8217;s case, it took seven months in the high-security Tihar jail 8212; which he qualifies as one of the 8216;8216;worst prisons in India8217;8217; 8212; before charges against him were withdrawn at the behest of former Defence Minister George Fernandes.

And significantly, Gilani writes, that at the time of his arrest in June 2002, there were 8216;8216;at least8217;8217; 30 other inmates in Tihar jail facing OS Act charges. Almost all the cases were moving at a painfully slow pace.

Besides the shocking description of the manner in which he was called a 8216;8216;traitor8217;8217; and thrashed by the inmates on his arrival he fainted at the end of it and the account of the rampant corruption inside the jail, Gilani writes about incidents which hurt his sensibilities as a journalist.

Like the 8216;8216;horror8217;8217; he experienced when one among the 60 men who had arrived at his house to search and arrest him decided to seal Dominique Lapierrer8217;s Freedom at Midnight also as a 8216;8216;contraband8217;8217; item.

The jail authorities took weeks for vetting books which his wife, Aanisa, caried for him to read. They even 8216;8216;disallowed8217;8217; Khushwant Singh8217;s biography and Nelson Mandela8217;s best-seller, A Long Walk to Freedom.

Story continues below this ad

Gilani narrates how after a month in Tihar, he was permitted to subscribe to a daily newspaper, as per prison rules. His choice was The Indian Express and this is what Gilani says happened: 8216;8216;When I received my copy the very next day, I was surprised to see only the two sports pages. When I asked the convict where the rest of the paper was he simply said the Express has reduced its pages to just two, and there was little I could do about it. In fact, all the other pages were censored as Express had carried an investigative story on the petrol pump scam.8217;8217;

Besides being denied such basic rights, Gilani lists the rules which Tihar authorities had unofficially imposed on the hapless inmates. For example, inamtes were not allowed to drink tea in cups; sit on a chair; they were always made to walk in queues; stop whenever they saw any jail official aproaching and adress him as 8216;8216;sir8217;8217; with folded hands. And so on.

8216;8216;Anyone breaking any of the above rules, even by mistake,8217;8217; Gilani writes, 8216;8216;would come in for drastic punishment. I once saw a prisoner thrashed at Deodhi gate because he had dared to drink water out of a cup8230; I also remember seeing an inmate punished for remaining seated on a bench outside the Deodhi when a doctor happened to pass by8230;.8217;8217;

It is evident from his narrative that the OSA case against him was the handiwork of the Intelligence Bureau and that, in fact, the Special Branch of Delhi Police initially refused to book him on such flimsy evidence. The back-up plan, which he became privy to later, was to take him to Jammu, 8216;8216;plant8217;8217; some RDX on him and then show it as a recovery.

Story continues below this ad

Eventually, the crucial 8216;8216;recovery8217;8217; made from his house was a 48-page booklet on deployment of forces in Kashmir, which was taken as a 8216;8216;secret sensitive document8217;8217; by members of the raiding party and even the then Home Minister, L.K. Advani, was informed about what a major seizure it was.

It was this document that Gilani8217;s lawyers and friends later proved in court was availible in the public domain, thus forcing the Government to withdraw the OS Act case. 8216;8216;But my heart goes out to those poor souls who I saw rotting behind bars in Tihar. They were not so fortunate as to have their version presented to the public through the press,8217;8217; writes Gilani.

His book also makes a strong case for what he calls 8216;8216;urgent course correction8217;8217; in the handling of OS Act cases. Several such cases have been listed in the book. Gilani says, the tendency to book people in and around Delhi under the Act has assumed 8216;8216;menacing proportions8217;8217;.

Ritu Sarin is Executive Editor (News and Investigations) at The Indian Express group. Her areas of specialisation include internal security, money laundering and corruption. Sarin is one of India’s most renowned reporters and has a career in journalism of over four decades. She is a member of the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) since 1999 and since early 2023, a member of its Board of Directors. She has also been a founder member of the ICIJ Network Committee (INC). She has, to begin with, alone, and later led teams which have worked on ICIJ’s Offshore Leaks, Swiss Leaks, the Pulitzer Prize winning Panama Papers, Paradise Papers, Implant Files, Fincen Files, Pandora Papers, the Uber Files and Deforestation Inc. She has conducted investigative journalism workshops and addressed investigative journalism conferences with a specialisation on collaborative journalism in several countries. ... Read More

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Loading Taboola...
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement