Premium
This is an archive article published on February 6, 2010
Premium

Opinion Sena hypocrisy

Does the Shiv Sena have a moral right to oppose Australian cricketers playing on Indian soil to protest attacks on Indians in Australia?....

The Indian Express

February 6, 2010 03:33 AM IST First published on: Feb 6, 2010 at 03:33 AM IST

Does the Shiv Sena have a moral right to oppose Australian cricketers playing on Indian soil to protest attacks on Indians in Australia? These attacks may partly be because local Australians feel Indians are taking away their jobs in a recession. Likewise,the Shiv Sena chases away other Indians from Maharashtra,because they are convinced that these “immigrants” are taking away jobs that rightly belong to the Marathi manoos. When they oppose Indians working on the Indian soil of Maharashtra,the Shiv Sena have little grounds to criticise Australians. Attacks,whether abroad or here,should be strongly condemned,but when the Shiv Sena does so,it smacks of opportunism.

— Shireen Bharucha

Pune

Stop the thugs

You have rightly observed that “The Senas derive an inflated sense of power by their rumoured capacity to disrupt a target’s legitimate business” (‘Fauji vs Sena’,IE,February 4). How many icons can the thugs take on? Mumbai belongs as much to all Indians as all of India belongs to every Mumbaikar. The nation’s financial capital can’t be left at the mercy of the Senas whose only contribution is bullying hapless labourers and using invectives against dissenting voices. Mumbai can’t be left to be held to ransom by a few lunatics,and Shah Rukh Khan doesn’t need to apologise for no mistake of his. The Thackerays need to apologise to the nation for their undemocratic demands and for threatening to suppress free voices.

— Manzar Imam

New Delhi

Fact check

Advertisement

This refers to the emotional outburst of Gul Panag in her article ‘Kudos to Shah Rukh Khan’ (IE,February 5). But she has got a few facts wrong which I would like to point out. She states that there is no problem in Delhi due to the influx of migrants. To the best of my knowledge,the chief minister of Delhi has cited this as a major problem at least four times. Problems between locals and migrants have started building up in Punjab as well. Panag proclaims that platforms like Twitter and Facebook are empowering the average citizen. I would like to enlighten her that nothing can replace the print media. The print media fought against the imperial rule of the British and the unlawful Emergency. No such mass movement has been with the new platforms.

— Sunil Kumar

New Delhi

An indiscretion

This refers to the editorial ‘Radical agent’ (IE,February 5). Why did Digvijay Singh keep quiet for so long before calling for a probe into the Batla House encounter? Where was he when the government honoured the cops involved in the encounter? It is disgusting to find the general secretary and a senior leader of the party leading the Union government indulging into worst kind of vote-bank politics. Singh’s has compromised public perceptions of the government’s fight against terror.

— M.C. Joshi

Lucknow

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments