Premium
This is an archive article published on June 20, 2009
Premium

Opinion Bottled up

The protests in Iran over allegations of the rigging of the presidential election indeed spring from long-term historical factors....

June 20, 2009 12:34 AM IST First published on: Jun 20, 2009 at 12:34 AM IST

•The protests in Iran over allegations of the rigging of the presidential election indeed spring from long-term historical factors. However,it’s also a battle between democracy and authoritarianism. The 1979 revolution was a popular uprising against the detested rule of Reza Shah Pehlavi. But,unfortunately,the new republic didn’t give people the desired freedom. With an overwhelmingly young population today,the bottled up forces of history now want to come out. The world is keenly watching whether “divine sovereignty” will put the genie of democracy,and “popular sovereignty”,back in the bottle.

— M. Ratan

New Delhi

CPM’s endgame?

•The challenge for the Left Front government comes not just from the Trinamool and the Maoists but also a chunk of its own erstwhile cadres (‘State & party’,and ‘Machine,Mamata,Maoists’,IE,June 19). The cause is misrule. A challenge reveals one’s strengths and weaknesses and leads to a confrontation with the truth. The CPM has ruled through the suppression of dissent. It is now helpless. The CPM can’t shrug off responsibility,given the situation. Perhaps the party has run its course. But other parties should think twice about aligning

or appearing to align with the Maoists.

— M.K.D. Prasada Rao

Ghaziabad

Advertisement

•Bloodletting in West Bengal triggered by a Maoist takeover of Lalgarh is a symptom of the miserable governance of the CPM and the resentment triggered by the highhandedness of the police. The Left’s culture of violence in Bengal is emblematic of its arrogance. Nandigram is a case in point. This cycle of retributive political violence,when combined with the Maoist threat,makes for a worrying prospect not only for Bengal but also India.

— Vitull K. Gupta

Bhatinda

Shopian politics

•It must be noted that every time a crime is committed,especially in a conflict zone,the victim is relegated and politics raises its hydra-headed face (‘After Shopian’,IE,June 15). I agree that “If a crime is addressed and handled as such,it keeps mischief-makers from playing politics over it”; but what about

investigative biases and political sycophancy? Commissions have been set up in the past,but they either fail or take a long time to bring any change. Both the media and the government need to take corrective action to stop this menace,which turn people rebellious.

— Manzar Imam

New Delhi

Democracy within

Advertisement

•This refers to the editorial ‘A royal takedown’ (IE,June 18). The Congress party’s note to members to drop feudal titles is ridiculous because the party itself runs on dynastic fuel,and that isn’t just about its first family. Just how many of the fresh faces in the new Manmohan Singh government are there because they rose,strenuously,through the ranks? There’s little evidence yet that India’s feudal political culture is being dumped.

Instead of issuing such a diktat,the Congress should develop inner-party

democracy.

— Manoj Parashar

Greater Noida

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments