Mamatas defeat in Haldia shows that her voters are standing up to ask questions
The results of the elections to six municipalities in West Bengal underscore the importance of reading between the statistics and beyond them. To go by the figures alone,Chief Minister Mamata Banerjees Trinamool Congress appears to have sustained its victorious wave from the 2011 assembly polls by pocketing four of the six civic bodies,where it had won only one by itself the last time. The TMC contested these polls alone against the Left Front as well as the Congress and raised its tally by 52 wards. But the devil has a penchant for lurking in the detail.
That significant detail is the municipality of Haldia in East Midnapore. All of the TMCs gains wash up against its defeat in Haldia,where its self-styled point person,Tamluk MP Suvendu Adhikari,had loudly proclaimed a clean sweep in the 26 wards. The TMC won only 11 of these and the CPM the remaining 15,in an exact reversal of voting patterns in the assembly elections. More importantly,the area around Nandigram,wherein Haldia lies,is where the TMCs turnaround had begun. The party had taken the wresting of the Haldia municipality from the CPM for granted. But it didnt happen. This decaying industrial town has left Banerjee with a question to ponder.
A year since coming to power,Banerjee will now have to factor this defeat into her assessment of TMC rule. Before next years panchayat elections,she has to dismantle the Haldia model where the old politics of vendetta had simply changed colour while staying intact,with no thought spared for development. The Haldia upset is also set in the larger context of Banerjees idiosyncratic governing style in Bengal and her increasing isolation outside it. Assam CM Tarun Gogoi,for instance,has spoken out against her strong-arm tactics on FDI in retail,criticising her infringement on another states right. By continuing to hold the country to ransom and disregarding everybody elses interests on the Teesta water-sharing agreement with Bangladesh,the enclave swap,the NCTC,or land acquisition Banerjee stands to lose much more than Haldia if she doesnt change course soon.