Premium
This is an archive article published on September 28, 2003

Umpires strike back at the Indians

It happens more with the Indians — getting marching orders in international matches — than others. In the Champions Trophy at Amst...

.

It happens more with the Indians — getting marching orders in international matches — than others. In the Champions Trophy at Amstelveen last month, skipper Dhanraj Pillay was shown the red card — he recieved an official warning as well — while in the Asia Cup semifinal against Korea yesterday, defender Kamalpreet Singh was booked after a heated argument.

The reasons, as experts in India say, are because the Indians are not fully conversant with the rules and by habit they challenge the umpires’ decisions. By contrast, the European players are more knowledgeable and also respect the umpiring decision.

The root of Indian players’ problems lie at domestic level tournaments. The players protest almost at will the moment an umpire blows the whistle. Five leading international umpires in the country — Shakeel Qureshi, Virender Bahadur Singh, Satinder Singh, Rajinder Gandhi and Suresh Bhatia — supervising the matches in the ongoing Gurmit Hockey Tournament here, blame it on the players for lack of knowledge about the game’s rules.

They also feel that umpiring in international tournaments is much easier than in domestic tournaments. ‘‘Because the players know the rules by heart. They don’t challenge the umpiring decision and respect the umpires,’’ says Shakeel Qureshi. The umpire from Bhopal is the most respected one with 72 international matches to his credit.

He adds, ‘‘We face little difficulty at international level. The European players keep themselves updating with the rule changes. They know where they have gone wrong. As a result, they do not question the decision. Moreover the captain is always there to control the situation.’’

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement