Premium
This is an archive article published on November 13, 1999

Jerusalem site feared death trap for pilgrims

JERUSALEM, NOV 12: At dawn each day for 800 years, a member of the same Muslim family has opened a door to Christianity's holiest shrine ...

.

JERUSALEM, NOV 12: At dawn each day for 800 years, a member of the same Muslim family has opened a door to Christianity8217;s holiest shrine in the holy land8217;s most sacred city.

But as the millennium year nears and crowds of the faithful swell behind doorkeeper Wajeeh Nuseibeh, Jerusalem8217;s church of the holy sepulchre is also being seen as something altogether more worldly 8212; a potential death trap for throngs of pilgrims.

To the horror of safety officials, the labyrinthine church, revered by Christians as the site of Christ8217;s crucifixion and burial, has but one door barely two metres yards wide

8220;There is an urgent need for a new emergency exit to prevent a possible catastrophe,8221; Israeli police spokeswoman Linda Menuhin said of the shrine in Jerusalem8217;s walled old city.

For years, police and emergency services have warned of 8220;nightmare scenarios8221; at the church, which can hold thousands of visitors.

They fear untold casualties from an extremist attack, whether by militants or the deranged, or from a panic-induced stampede.

The delicately lit interior of the 11th century church is a safety expert8217;s worst curse, a warren of blind alleys and dead ends. Structural damage is still evident and unaddressed after two major fires and an earthquake over the past 200 years.

Story continues below this ad

Escape routes from the church, shared uneasily by three branches of Christianity, pose a further threat. The paths lead away through a bustling souk market area studded with uneven paving slabs and slippery stone stairs.

Regarding the holy sepulchre, Israel maintains it has tried for four years to reopen some of the 10 sealed doors that offered access to the church when it was built in 1042 on the ruins of a Roman basilica.

It says squabbling between the Roman Catholic, Armenian, and Greek orthodox churches has barred all efforts at change.

Even in a city where religious conflicts are as commonplace as traffic snarls, the zealously guarded status quo of the holy sepulchre 8212; subdivided into areas ruled by the three denominations 8212; is noteworthy.

Story continues below this ad

A special ministerial committee is to meet on November 16 in a renewed effort to find a way to solve the door jam.

Doorkeeper Nuseibeh, 47, said any move to change the status quo would be playing with fire, not least because of the sensitivities that stem from Israel8217;s hold over the holy city.

8220;A door will wreck the balance,8221; he said. 8220;Israel wants the door for politics 8212; they want to show they are directors here.8221;

in an elaborate ritual enacted each morning and night, Nuseibeh follows his forebears up a ladder to work an ancient, conical iron lock from the outside of the church.

Story continues below this ad

Another Muslim clan has formal possession of the key. The Christian denominations take turns pushing the ladder out to Nuseibeh in the darkness through a small portal.

8220;This position has been passed down in my family, father to son, from the time of the Caliph Omar, in the year 636 AD. When the crusaders came, they threw out the orthodox Christians and killed 70,000 Muslims in Jerusalem.8221;

Nuseibeh8217;s family fled north and resumed its work when the Muslim hero Saladin retook the holy land in the 13th century.

8220;We are a family here,8221; said Nuseibeh, a 25-year veteran of the lock detail, who expects his eldest son to succeed him.

Story continues below this ad

8220;We have been happy and everything has been fine for 800 years. People are safe. They don8217;t need the door, the trouble.8221;

But even the placid Nuseibeh conceded a shred of concern for the easter holy fire observance, when as many as 3,000 devout orthodox Christians pack the church, lit candles in hand.

Up to 12,000 more clog a courtyard beside the door, waiting their turn.

Leaving the church, Canadian Geraldine Spahn, 32, shook her head and smiled when asked if she feared a disaster there.

Story continues below this ad

8220;I have to believe that in a place like this, Jesus will take care of his own.8221;

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement