‘Your comments embarrassed the party’: JD(U) MP who spoke against SIR gets show-cause notice
Speaking outside Parliament on Wednesday, Banka MP Giridhari Yadav had called the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar a “Tughlaqi farman”
Written by Himanshu Harsh
Patna | Updated: July 25, 2025 04:00 AM IST
3 min read
Whatsapp
twitter
Facebook
Reddit
The MP had clarified that he was giving his “personal opinion” and it “doesn't matter what his party is saying”.
The JD(U) has issued a show-cause notice to its MP Giridhari Yadav, who had on Wednesday called the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar a “Tughlaqi farman” (ill-conceived diktat).
Yadav, the Banka MP from JD(U), Bihar’s ruling party and a BJP ally, had said outside the Parliament, “Election Commission has no practical knowledge. It neither knows the history nor the geography of Bihar; it knows nothing.”
“It took 10 days for me to arrange all the documents,” the parliamentarian said, adding that his son lives in America. “How will he do the signature in just a month?” he said. “This (SIR) has been imposed on us forcefully. “Ye Tughlaqi farman hai chunav aayog ka.”
The MP had clarified that he was giving his “personal opinion” and it “doesn’t matter what his party is saying”.
The show-cause notice signed by Afaque Ahmad Khan, the party’s national general secretary, states, “You are aware that certain opposition parties, frustrated by their electoral outcomes, have been running a sustained campaign to discredit ECI, particularly on the issue of Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs), with the sole objective of creating public doubt over the functioning of a constitutional body.”
“Our party, the Janata Dal (United), has consistently supported the ECI and the use of EVMs, both during our time in the INDIA alliance and now as part of the NDA alliance,” it states. “In this context, your public comments on such a sensitive matter, especially in an election year, not only cause embarrassment to the party but also inadvertently lend credibility to the baseless and politically motivated allegations made by the opposition.”
“JD(U) views your conduct as a lapse in discipline and not in consonance with the party’s stated position on the matter. You are therefore hereby called upon to show cause within 15 days of receipt of this. notice, failing which disciplinary action may be initiated against you,” it states.
Story continues below this ad
Speaking to The Indian Express on Wednesday, Yadav had also said, “People are complaining about the bureaucratic hurdles they are facing and what a pain it is to get documents (for SIR). At many places, officials are asking for bribes, the people in my constituency have told me.”
Himanshu Harsh is a Correspondent with The Indian Express, currently leading on-the-ground coverage in Bihar. With a reporting career rooted in the complexities of the National Capital Region (NCR), Himanshu specializes in the critical intersection of law, crime, and civic governance.
Professional Expertise & Credentials
An alumnus of the prestigious Indian Institute of Mass Communication (IIMC), Delhi, Himanshu brings a rigorous academic foundation to his investigative work. His expertise is characterized by a "ground-up" reporting style, most notably demonstrated during his extensive coverage of the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, where he analyzed shifting political landscapes and grassroots sentiment.
Specialized Beats
Himanshu’s portfolio reflects versatility, allowing him to navigate diverse industries and social issues:
Civic & Legal Affairs: Extensive experience covering the Delhi reporting beat, focusing on policy implementation and judicial impact.
Automotive Industry: A technical background in reporting on India’s evolving transport and automotive sectors.
Social Fabric & Human Interest: Beyond hard news, he is known for exploring the changing social dynamics of India’s urban and rural heartlands, bringing a human-centric lens to systemic issues.
Personal Interests & Digital Literacy
Outside the newsroom, Himanshu’s deep engagement with technology and gaming informs his understanding of digital trends and the modern information economy. A trained DJ with a passion for music, his diverse personal interests contribute to a well-rounded perspective that resonates across both traditional and digital media platforms. ... Read More