Premium
This is an archive article published on August 16, 2013

Music review Satyagraha: Minority appeal

The compositions in Prakash Jha's <i>Satyagraha</i>—Democracy Under Fire,a political thriller,do generate some smoke.

The compositions in Prakash Jha’s Satyagraha—Democracy Under Fire,a political thriller,do generate some smoke,but the fire is missing. After working with Pritam,Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy and Aadesh Srivastav,Jha experiments with Salim-Sulaiman’s music this time. Satyagraha brings the two composers to the forefront,but while a couple of tracks are brilliant,others are plain forgettable.

The album opens with Shafqat Amanat Ali’s Ras ke bhare,in raag Darbari. A thumri attempted by Srivastav,it distinctly reminds us of Mora piya from Raajneeti,also a Srivastav composition. The song lies in Ali’s comfort zone but fails to create the magic Ali’s voice is capable of (remember Mora saiyaan and Mitwa?). In this track,Ali’s voice sounds jaded,despite having been churned out of a host of

voice machines.

The synth interludes give the track a rock-thumri feel but one wonders why does Srivastav have Arpita Chakraborty whispering tabla bols at regular intervals? She fails to add anything to an otherwise well-orchestrated composition. The track’s house mix may sound interesting to some as it comes with well-blended percussion and electronic sounds. Janta rocks,shockingly,reminds us of Devang Patel’s Stop that,followed by touches of Hindustan meri jaan from Border. It’s as if the two have been mishmashed with some electronic riffs. Not done. Joshi’s lyrics also don’t have the sharpness needed for a satire. Then comes Hum bole the,one of the stronger tracks. I love the way the song gets a glistening quality through an excellent use of guitar,an Indian Ocean USP. Also,there is Rahul Ram’s voice,which may not sound as effortless as it used to,but this,right here,is an edgy composition with rakish energy. In Raghupati raghav raja,the age-old tune is taken as the basic tune and brilliantly blended with Rajiv Sudarshan’s voice. Salim-Sulaiman deliver an ace with this one.

The first line of Hamari atariya is a note by note replication of Baawri si preet (also a Salim-Sulaiman composition) from Kurbaan. I don’t appreciate the self-plagiarism here but barring the first line,the composition changes its course with Shweta Pandit sounding radiant. The problem lies in heavy electronic sounds which make it all sound warped. Jha needs to try the old-school concept of one composer for a film. As of now there are too many cooks and the broth is edible,but we are nowhere close to licking the bowl.

Click here to follow Screen Digital on YouTube and stay updated with the latest from the world of cinema.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement