This is an archive article published on October 21, 2015
RSS’s ‘technical’ problem: Saffron organisation needs change in mindset
The RSS, which is virtually running the BJP’s first majority government (though it denies this), is still to realize that its activities can’t remain unscrutinised by the media or ordinary citizens.
The Panchjanya cover (left); Dadri victim Mohammed Akhlaq (right)
Whenever there is a controversy which involves a frontal organization of the RSS, its first reaction is to distance itself from that organ — on technical grounds. So, when an article in Panchjanya embarrassed the RSS by virtually justifying the Dadri lynching, its reaction was to clarify that the Panchjanya weekly is not its publication. Prachar Pramukh Manmohan Vaidya said it was ‘not the mouthpiece of the RSS’.
The RSS is adept at proving you wrong – technically. If you say the BJP is its political outfit or that the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) is its student wing, it will disagree. And technically, it is correct: both are separate entities which subscribe to the ideology of RSS just as the Panchjanya is a weekly registered with Registrar of Newspapers of India (RNI) as a publication in its own right although it mouths RSS ideology.
[related-post]
The major problem with the RSS is its mindset. When there are meetings of senior RSS functionaries, journalists gathered outside the venue find it difficult to learn about the agenda or the participants, etc.
Story continues below this ad
In the late nineties, when MG Vaidya was appointed spokesperson, there was a proper channel of communication and it was easier, but when the leadership realized that his successor Ram Madhav spoke to the media more than RSS wanted him to, it withdrew him and abolished the post of spokesperson. It said that Prachar Pramukh Manmohan Vaidya would speak to media when required. This is clearly out of step with the times when instant communication is so necessary.
Even the armed forces have changed in the last two decades. Now serving officers meet the media and media persons have access to their activities. The RSS, its activities are still out of bounds to the media and often it doesn’t even reveal the bare facts of its programmes. It is not that they have some secret activities going on, it is just an entrenched mindset.
The RSS, which is virtually running the BJP’s first majority government (though it denies this), is still to realize that its activities can’t remain unscrutinised by the media or ordinary citizens. Its pracharaks and several leaders are often seen virtually dictating to ministers and officers but they refuse to be accountable – rather like the case of 10, Janpath in the UPA governments
So, if one of the prominent publications an article as it did, the RSS ought to have stood by that. And if it felt that it was wrong to publish such article, it should have fixed responsibility for that. The problem with the RSS, however, is that it will not do so, it will always distance itself from its organs – on technical grounds.
Shyamlal Yadav is one of the pioneers of the effective use of RTI for investigative reporting. He is a member of the Investigative Team. His reporting on polluted rivers, foreign travel of public servants, MPs appointing relatives as assistants, fake journals, LIC’s lapsed policies, Honorary doctorates conferred to politicians and officials, Bank officials putting their own money into Jan Dhan accounts and more has made a huge impact. He is member of the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ). He has been part of global investigations like Paradise Papers, Fincen Files, Pandora Papers, Uber Files and Hidden Treasures. After his investigation in March 2023 the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York returned 16 antiquities to India. Besides investigative work, he keeps writing on social and political issues. ... Read More