The Calcutta High Court on Thursday dismissed a plea filed by three Jharkhand Congress MLAs seeking a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) inquiry into their arrest. The West Bengal Police arrested Jamtara MLA Irfan Ansari, Kolebira legislator Naman Bixal Kongari, and Khijri MLA Rajesh Kacchap on July 31 after more than Rs 50 lakh in cash was seized from their SUV. The West Bengal Criminal Investigation Department (CID) is now investigating the case and the party has suspended the three.
Ansari’s name did the rounds last year when there was an alleged attempt to topple the government. In July 2021, Bixal alleged that he had been offered Rs 1 crore by “some people” to bring down the government. Following the arrest of the three, the Congress MLA from Bermo, Kumar Jaimangal, filed a complaint alleging a bid to topple the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM)-Congress-RJD government in the state, with an offer of Rs 10 crore per MLA. He also alleged that the MLAs had lured him to meet Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma.
Here is a look at the assets and liabilities that the three legislators arrested in West Bengal and Jaimangal declared in their affidavits to the Election Commission before the 2019 Jharkhand Assembly elections.
Sources of income: Business and salary drawn as an MLA
Total income shown in Income Tax returns:
Rs 30.47 lakh (2018-’19)
Rs 30.03 lakh (2017-’18)
Rs 11.68 lakh (2016-’17)
Rs 7.68 lakh (2015-’16)
Rs 24.2 lakh (2014-’15)
Movable assets
Self: Rs 1.67 crore
Wife: Rs 6.53 lakh
Cash in hand
Self: Rs 4.9 lakh
Wife: Rs 1.58 lakh
Bank deposits
Self: Rs 1.45 crore
Wife: Rs 4,000
Policies and shares — Jindal shares: Rs 2 Lakh; Life Insurance Premium: Rs 2 lakh; National Savings
Certificate: Rs 10,000
Other assets – Wife: Rs 4.91 lakh
Car: Rs 12.87 lakh
Immovable assets
Gross value: Rs 91 lakh (inherited: None)
Agricultural land: None
Non-agricultural land: 18,000 sq ft bought in 2006 for Rs 17,000 plus Rs 2-lakh investment on the land; current market value: Rs 7 lakh
Commercial buildings: 30,000 sq ft in Madhupur, purchased for Rs 14 lakh in 2002; current market price: Rs 62 lakh
Residential building in Lakshmi Nagar, New Delhi, bought in 2006 for Rs 4 lakh; current value: Rs 22 lakh
Total liabilities: Rs 30 lakh, commercial loan
Government dues: Rs 49.3 lakh payable to Jharkhand Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited
Criminal cases (as per Association for Democratic Reforms): Five pending, charges filed in one for cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property.
Sources of income: Owner of a truck and joint owner of a stone crusher unit (Brothers Suraksha Stoneworks) plus salary drawn as an MLA
Total income shown in Income Tax returns:
Rs 5.5 lakh (2019-’20)
Rs 5.45 lakh (2018-’19)
Rs 4.6 lakh (2017-’18)
Rs 4.06 lakh (2016-’17)
Rs 3.15 lakh (2015-’16)
Movable assets
Self: Rs 34 lakh
Wife: Rs 9.96 lakh
Cash in hand
Self: Rs 80,000
Wife: Rs 10,000
Bank deposits
Self: Rs 14,000 approximately
Wife: Rs 4,000 approximately
Jewellery: Gold, 230 gm, worth Rs 8.74 lakh and silver, 2.25 kg, worth Rs 1.08 lakh
Policies and shares: Two life insurance policies with maturity amount of Rs 12 lakh
Four motor vehicles worth Rs 21.06 lakh
Immovable assets
Gross value Rs 1.84 crore (inherited assets: Rs 63.22 lakh)
Total Agricultural land: 8.43 acres, market value Rs 63.22 lakh; non-farm land: 2.37 acres, value at time of purchase: Rs 21.5 lakh, current market value: Rs 86.72 lakh
Residential six-room house (current market value): Rs 35 lakh
Total liabilities: Rs 13.09 lakh
Vehicle loan: Rs 12.18 lakh
Dues: Rs 91,000
Criminal cases: None
Sources of Income: Agriculture, pension and salary drawn as an MLA
Total income shown in Income Tax returns: Not available
Movable assets
Total value: Rs 6.45 lakh
Cash in hand: Rs 1 lakh
Bank deposits: Rs 3.2 lakh
Jewellery: Gold, 20 gm, valued at Rs 74,000; Car: Rs 1.5 lakh; Motorbike: Rs 80,000
Immovable assets
Gross value: Rs 38.8 lakh (all inherited)
Agricultural land: 19.88 acres, current market value Rs 20 lakh; non-agricultural land: 22,215 sq ft, current market value Rs 8.5 lakh
Residential buildings: 1,800 sq ft built-up area with current estimated value of Rs 10.3 lakh
Liabilities
Kisan Credit Card Loan: Rs 82,527
Criminal cases: Two pending, including one in which charges were framed under the Representation of People Act on July 2, 2019
Sources of income: Business and salary drawn as an MLA
Total income shown in Income Tax returns:
Self: Rs 7.45 lakh ( 2020-’21)
Rs 11.70 lakh (2019-’20)
Rs 16.90 lakh (2018-’19)
Rs 9.93(2015-’16)
Rs 8.89 lakh (2014-’15)
Wife: Rs 5.76 lakh (2020-’21)
Rs 4.79lakh (2019-’20)
Rs 5.21 lakh (2018-’19)
Rs 4.48 lakh (2015-’16)
Rs 3 lakh ( 2014-’15)
Tax returns figures for both not available for 2016-’17 and 2017-’18
Movable assets
Cash in hand: Rs 19.66 lakh; wife: Rs 7.25 lakh
Gold and silver: Rs 8.47 lakh; wife: Rs 4.49 lakh
Immovable assets: Nil
Liabilities: Nil
Criminal cases: One pending