Taxing proposals

The task force has made some concessions to the concern expressed by none other than the Union finance minister himself by conceding that tax concessions may be retained in the case of housing loans to a limited section of the middle income groups. However, the committee has rejected Jaswant Singh8217;s argument that the government cannot 8216;renege8217; on commitments made to the taxpayer by claiming that the doctrine of 8216;promissory estopel8217; does not hold in the realm of tax policy and that the state can change tax policies in the public interest. The Kelkar committee has also stuck to its guns on the proposal to end taxation of dividend incomes in the hands of shareholders. In theory, no one can object to the wide gamut of policy changes recommended by the task force because, taken as a whole, they do pass the test of equity and efficiency in taxation.

The second report on indirect taxes provoked less controversy and was more widely welcomed. Both in the area of direct and indirect taxes the real challenge facing the government is to improve tax administration. Indeed, it is this part of the report that is more important and deserves early acceptance and implementation. If the government can focus all its attention on improvements in tax administration alone it can vastly improve the ratio of tax collections to national income. There are many practical and useful ideas on reducing transactions cost, increasing transparency and making the tax administration more user friendly and less corrupt that must be seriously taken up. The finance minister should not yield to the temptation of accepting some of the more populist proposals, like the ones relating to increasing the minimum taxable threshold income level or ending taxation of dividend income in the hands of the shareholders while not implementing the less popular ones, especially the elimination of exemptions and of a variety of tax holidays. That will go against the spirit of the Kelkar committee8217;s 8216;all-or-nothing8217; approach. Indeed, it will also go against the principle of fairness in taxation.

Curated For You

For a month and a half, I was just in my room: When Sania Mirza reflected on struggling with depression after a career-changing injury

She worked for only two years, delivered only classics and blockbusters; Mohanlal once saved her life at Kodaikanals Suicide Point

Not sure if Ill be back: Neha Kakkar announces break from relationships, work after brutal Candy Shop backlash