Premium
This is an archive article published on September 12, 2012

Facebook apologises for banning US magazine’s cartoon over showing too much nipple

Facebook has apologised for temporarily shutting down The New Yorker Cartoons page.

Facebook has apologised for temporarily shutting down The New Yorker Cartoons page over one particular cartoon of Adam and Eve that shows the pair totally nude.

A mocking redo of Adam and Eve with the pair in bulky clothes was misunderstood as a serious attempt to appease Facebook’s obscenity patrol,the New York Daily News reported.

But that wasn’t the only funny business facing New Yorker cartoon editor Bob Mankoff,who also had to correct several media outlets that fell for a joke he and the artist made soon after the alleged censorship.

Story continues below this ad

Drawn by Mick Stevens,the cartoon shows the first man and woman sitting shirtless beneath an apple tree.

Eve’s nipples are represented by small,black dots,which ultimately got the magazine banned from Facebook for breaching community standards,Mankoff wrote in a blog post on Monday.

Facebook’s policy prohibits not only “any obvious sexual activity,” but also “naked ‘private parts’ including female nipple bulges and naked butt cracks; male nipples are ok,” Gawker discovered earlier this year.

In order to poke a little fun at the social networking site,the artist redrew the cartoon for Mankoff’s blog post,with Adam and Eve wearing bulky sweaters and long pants.

Story continues below this ad

This,Mankoff joked,was an attempt “to get back into Facebook’s good graces.”

He wrote that “the gain in clothes caused too great a loss in humor.”

Not getting this joke — and seeming to believe that a prominent magazine and frequent defender of free speech would actually redraft its content to please Facebook — New York media outlets Gawker and the Daily Intel reported that this clothed picture was a serious attempt to placate,Mankoff wrote.

“I feel compelled to state the obvious because the obvious wasn’t obvious to Gawker,” he wrote.

Story continues below this ad

Facebook has aroused freedom of expression concerns many times before,from accusations of biases like homophobia for censoring a gay kiss in 2011 to claims that it fosters intolerance towards religious people.

Responding to what the New Yorker is now calling “Nipplegate,” Facebook told the Daily News the incident was completely unintended.

“Recently,Facebook mistakenly blocked a cartoon as part of our efforts to keep the site safe for all and quickly worked to rectify the mistake as soon as we were notified,” a Facebook spokesperson said.

Apologizing for “any inconvenience,” the site’s spokesperson said its policies are enforced by a team of reviewers in several offices across the globe.

Story continues below this ad

“This team looks at hundreds of thousands of reports every week,and as you might expect,occasionally,we make a mistake and block a piece of content we shouldn’t have. We have already taken steps to prevent this from happening in the future,” they said.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement