Premium
This is an archive article published on April 30, 2002

Mamata stand will cost her, says aide

Mamata Banerjee’s Muslim constituency in Bengal is in a shambles. A day before the crucial vote in Parliament Sultan Ahmed, an importan...

.

Mamata Banerjee’s Muslim constituency in Bengal is in a shambles. A day before the crucial vote in Parliament Sultan Ahmed, an important minority leader and a Trinamool general secretary, told The Indian Express that the party’s stand so far on Gujarat has severely eroded the TMC’s secular credentials and voting in favour of the NDA will cause more damage.

This, at a time when Trinamool’s — and Mamata’s — popularity in the state has been on the wane, particularly after Gujarat. One sit-in rally in Kolkata — her happy hunting ground — earlier this month drew around 300 people.

Ahmed said members of the community who were politically aligned with the TMC were feeling ‘‘isolated’’. ‘‘Communal riots are nothing new in India. But Gujarat stands out because it was state-sponsored rioting and any party which calls itself secular has to take a firm stand against it’’, he said.

Story continues below this ad

However, he said he appreciated the fact that Mamata had little choice. ‘‘Our leader came out of the NDA alliance when she should have been there (referring to Mamata quitting the railway ministry before the last Assembly polls in Bengal). And now she has to put her strength behind the NDA when there is nothing left of it except liabilities.’’

Other Muslim leaders within the party — speaking on condition of anonymity — also said the community was ‘‘hurt’’. Mamata, they pointed out, had fought against TADA and other issues, earning confidence of the community. But her vacililation over Gujarat has hardly been overlooked.

Even smaller parties like the Party for Democratic Socialism (PDS, floated by Saifuddin Chowdhury/Samir Pututunda) and Socialist Unity Centre of India have organized protest rallies in Kolkata over the carnage in Gujarat. But not the Trinamool.

‘‘It has been difficult for us to convince our community members about her silence. Many of our community members came and told us that they felt isolated and insecure. We are under pressure and feel like hiding our face. But what can she do? The situation is critically poised’’, said one leader.

Story continues below this ad

The Shahi Imam of the city’s Tipu Sultan mosque, long a Mamata supporter, also sounded dejected. ‘‘One had hoped that the TMC would pursue the secular line but many of our community members are depressed by its stand.’’

He also came down hard on other ‘‘so-called secular parties’’. ‘‘Where is the Congress, where are Mulayam Singh, Laloo Prasad, Chandrababu Naidu? Couldn’t these parties take their supporters to Gujarat to stop the violence instead of issuing mere statements?’’

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement