Premium
This is an archive article published on June 4, 2004

Jewish labour camp…Mumbai shop, a daughter connects the dots

It's a story straight out of a Roman Polanski movie: a missing man, a family’s pain, an unexpected clue and a trip across the globe to ...

.

It’s a story straight out of a Roman Polanski movie: a missing man, a family’s pain, an unexpected clue and a trip across the globe to explore a missing link.

All her life, Monica Csango, a 35-year-old journalist, had heard hundreds of stories about her grandfather Ferenc Csango, a Hungarian Jew, who was deported to a labour camp in Russia during World War II.Ferenc disappeared in 1943 and was never seen again by his family. His fate remained a mystery until a traveller walked into the Csango Noitaskak leather goods shop in Budapest — set up by Ferenc — and asked if they had a branch in Mumbai. The store in Mumbai, by the same name, also sold similar products.

Stunned by the connection, Ferenc’s wife Magda told her son Peter about it. But the trail fell cold as Peter, a scientist living in Norway, did not attach much importance to the ‘discovery’.

Story continues below this ad

Then, years later, in 2002, Peter’s daughter Monica convinced him to renew the search. The reluctant scientist used the Internet to get in touch with the owners of Csango in Mumbai, who wrote back saying they had purchased the shop from Harry Sopher, an Iraqi Jew.

Correspondence with Sopher’s nephews in London — Sopher had passed away in 2000 — revealed that Harry had purchased the store from a Hungarian named Csango. It was too big a coincidence to ignore. And Monica and Peter decided to make the trip. They reached Mumbai on May 25.

The first person they spoke to was Dilip Narang, the present owner of Csango, Colaba. But Narang only knew Sopher. A visit to the registration archives at the Indian Merchants Chamber revealed that the store was set up by an N Haim which, incidentally, was the name of Ferenc’s grandfather.

The next bit of information boosted Monica’s hopes further: ‘‘We spoke to Prakash Malik, owner of Ali Baba restaurant, close to Csango. He recognised my grandfather’s photograph.’’ That’s where the hunt stands now. The father-daughter duo are spending nearly 14 hours every day, trying to solve the mystery. Solomon Sopher, head of the Jewish community in Mumbai, is also on the trail. A trip to the local Jewish cemetery has proved futile. The next step: Going through old Jewish death records. If that too fails, Sopher says he will ‘‘speak to old Jewish people. We’ll succeed.’’

Story continues below this ad

But time’s running out. The father and daughter are scheduled to leave Mumbai on Saturday. Monica is determined though. ‘‘I will come back if we have to.’’ (Monica and Peter can be contacted at 022-22840229 or e-mail them at monicacsango @hotmail.com and csangopeter@yahoo.com)

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement