Premium
This is an archive article published on February 24, 2006

Bird flu is also about security

The bird flu outbreak in India has revealed that we are a “risk society”, the phrase made popular by noted German sociologist, Dr ...

.

The bird flu outbreak in India has revealed that we are a “risk society”, the phrase made popular by noted German sociologist, Dr Ulrich Beck. For the last few months the H5N1 virus was infecting various countries and it was only a matter of time before the Indian poultry sector found itself at risk. This signifies that risks have become all prevailing and there seems little escape from them. Yet most countries do not take these risks seriously enough because they essentially do not form a part of their conventional security apparatus.

For countries like India, which traditionally define their security only in military terms, such threats pose new challenges. In this era of terrorism the chances of conventional wars between two nation-states are slowly diminishing. The current security landscape for countries like India contains numerous non-military challenges to their security. This emerging new class of non-military threats has the potential to destabilise India and reverse decades of hard work in social and economic sectors. India faces threats because of overpopulation, cross-border terrorism, environmental degradation, health issues, corruption, and internal disputes arising out of scarcity of natural resources and employment.

There is, therefore, an urgent need for Indian authorities to re-jig their security concerns. Many problems demand resolutions that are beyond military solutions. The bird flu incidence has shown the potential damage a virus can do to the economy. Interestingly, the damage to the economy is done more by the “fear virus” than the actual virus. Luckily, to date this fear of disease spread is only restricted to poultry stock. If this infection jumps from birds to human beings and if human-to-human transmission begins to manifest itself, the situation could become unmanageable.

Story continues below this ad

In the past when Surat was confronted with the plague, more than half its population had run away within 48 hours. Today many countries, including India, are not in a position to handle any such sudden disease spread. One reason for this ineptness could be that as a nation we are not addressing the comprehensive security concerns with respect to non-military threats properly. Especially after 9/11 and the US declaration of the war on terror, many states have stopped addressing “real” security issues. This is not to argue that terrorism is not an important issue. In fact the classical definition of non-military threats clearly identifies terrorism as its own sub-set. However, where we are possibly making a mistake is in not appreciating the fact that during the last few years in many parts of the world human security has been challenged more often than national security.

The spread of diseases like bird flu is an indicator of future global challenges to human security and demands much greater attention than the mere stockpiling of Tamiflu.

The writer is a defence analyst

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement