Premium
This is an archive article published on October 2, 2015

Why Gujarat’s new scheme for students is probably only empty words

Science, Arts, Commerce and Education students in self-financed colleges will get a 50% fee waiver, or annual assistance of Rs 10,000, whichever is lesser.

Mukhyamantri Yuva Swavalamban Yojana, MYSY, fee-waiver/scholarship scheme, scholarship scheme, poor undergraduate students, Gujarat Anandiben Patel announces education pacakage for EWS in Gandhinagar Thursday. (Source: Express Photo)

On September 24, the Gujarat government announced the Mukhyamantri Yuva Swavalamban Yojana (MYSY), a fee-waiver/scholarship scheme for poor undergraduate students. The scheme is widely seen as a response to the Patidar agitation for reservation in college education and government jobs; agitation leader Hardik Patel, however, rejected the MYSY almost immediately as a “lollipop”, which he said offered nothing substantive to his community. The government also relaxed by five years the hiring age for government jobs across all categories.

The Scheme

Under the Rs 1,000 crore scheme, the government pays 50% of the fee, up to a maximum of Rs 2 lakh per year, for undergraduate students of medicine in self-financed (private) and government medical colleges. Students of dental sciences, homoeopathy, nursing and physiotherapy get a 50% fee waiver or an assistance of Rs 2 lakh, whichever is lesser. Students of Classes X and XII opting for diploma courses with at least 80 percentile marks will qualify for annual assistance of Rs 25,000, or a 50% fee waiver, whichever is lesser. Science, Arts, Commerce and Education students in self-financed colleges will get a 50% fee waiver, or annual assistance of Rs 10,000, whichever is lesser. The assistance is skewed in favour of professional institutes, whereas nearly half the state’s students enroll in Arts, Science and Commerce streams.

The Beneficiaries

Gujarat Board (GSHSEB), CBSE, ICSE, IB and NIOS students who secure 90 percentile in Class 12, and who have an annual family income of up to Rs 4.5 lakh. Nearly 60,000 students could benefit, it is estimated.

MYSY and MSY

On July 23, 2014, the government replaced all existing scholarship schemes with a consolidated Mukhyamantri Shishyavrutti Yojana (MSY) to extend “financial help to bright, needy undergraduate students”. A similar ‘CM scholarship scheme’ notified on March 3, 2014 by the previous Narendra Modi government too, was scrapped. MSY and MYSY are largely similar schemes, though differing in reach. MSY lowers the bar in some cases to bring a larger group in the beneficiary tent. It also incorporates a provision for girls — in 50 talukas with a female literacy rate of under 50%, there are 500 scholarships for girls with 75% or higher marks in Class 12, irrespective of the families’ annual income.

MYSY and Patidars

The scheme is a knee-jerk reaction, which doesn’t offer much of substance to economically weaker sections. Raising the age ceiling for jobs is likely to increase competition, given the large numbers of jobless older than 30. Existing ceilings of 28 (general category) and 33 (reserved) will now be 33 and 38 years respectively. More significant is the fact that the government has not recruited teachers on full pay scales after 1998 — until that happens, these steps will remain of notional value.

The ‘Real’ Gainers

MYSY will pay for education in private colleges, many of which are run by politicians. They will gain if the large number of seats that currently go empty are filled. Because no cap on fees has been specified, there is speculation that private colleges may now charge more. The government has also made no reference to increasing capacities in professional colleges and institutes run by it.

The Funding

There is no clarity on funding for the Rs 1,000 crore package. There is no budgetary allocation. No notification has been issued regarding its implementation.

Ritu Sharma is an Assistant Editor with The Indian Express' Gujarat bureau, an editorial position that reflects her experience and Authority in regional journalism. With over a decade of concentrated reporting experience, she is a highly Trustworthy and specialized journalist, especially noted for her Expertise in the education sector across Gujarat and previously Chandigarh. Expertise Primary Authority (Education): With over ten years of dedicated reporting on education in both Gujarat and Chandigarh, Ritu Sharma is a foremost authority on educational policy, institutional governance, and ground realities from "KG to PG." Her coverage includes: Higher Education: In-depth scrutiny of top institutions like IIM-Ahmedabad (controversies over demolition/restoration of heritage architecture), IIT-Bombay (caste discrimination issues), and new initiatives like international branch campuses in GIFT City. Schooling & Policy: Detailed coverage of government schemes (Gyan Sadhana School Voucher Scheme), the implementation and impact of the Right to Education (RTE) Act, teacher recruitment issues, and the impact of national policies like the NEP. Student Welfare: Reporting on critical issues such as suicide allegations due to caste discrimination, and the challenges faced by students (e.g., non-delivery of NAMO tablets). ... Read More

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement