Premium
This is an archive article published on January 3, 2024

Dave Chappelle The Dreamer review: Controversial comedian promises to ‘keep punching down’ in mean-spirited Netflix standup special

Dave Chappelle The Dreamer review: Like a theoretical physicist helping the Nazis during World War II, or a surgeon dedicating his life to stealing kidneys, the legendary comedian isn’t exactly putting his skills to good use.

Rating: 2.5 out of 5
dave chappelle the dreamerDave Chappelle in a still from his new Netflix special, The Dreamer.

Dave Chappelle opens his latest Netflix special, The Dreamer, with a masterfully constructed joke, combining his penchant for autobiographical storytelling with his trademark laid-back delivery. It’s a pity, then, that he unleashes it in the service of a truly despicable punchline directed at, you guessed it, trans people. In a world populated by plenty of real villains — racists, corrupt politicians, warmongers — Chappelle has decided, for some obscure reason, to make the queer community his enemy. And it’s truly tragic to watch one of the greatest comics of all time devote his talent to pettiness that would be viewed with pity even on a school playground.

In fact, watching him perform in recent years can immediately transform you into a middle-aged Indian schoolteacher. “This boy had so much potential,” you think to yourself, as you shake your head in regret. But like a theoretical physicist helping the Nazis during World War II or a surgeon dedicating his life to stealing kidneys, Chappelle isn’t exactly putting his skills to good use. And to top it all, he just can’t seem to stop viewing himself as the wronged party in all of this.

Also read – Ricky Gervais Armageddon review: Provocative comedian dusts off dated material in latest Netflix standup special

Story continues below this ad

Chappelle’s unprompted knife-fight against the trans community made him a cause célèbre a couple of years ago, leading to an internal conflict at Netflix, but crucially, nary a condemnation from his own people. Most comedians appeared to be afraid that by criticising Chappelle’s politics, they might endanger their own freedom of speech. Or, perhaps they simply share the same beliefs as him. Who knows? Either way, the streamer seems to be reveling in the debate, as it continues to disregard the bad press that being in business with Chappelle is bringing.

In The Dreamer, the comedian vows to keep ‘punching down’, a statement of purpose that comes across more like a tantrum than the brave act of artistic defiance that Chappelle clearly views it as. Unlike the equally provocative Ricky Gervais, whose humour is laced with stinging satire directed at the elite, Chappelle’s punchlines are invariably aimed at those who can’t really defend themselves. For instance, when he makes a joke at the expense of ‘handicapped’ people — he also mocks them physically — there are no hidden layers. He isn’t calling out the healthcare industry for holding certain people hostage and milking them for money. He isn’t even giving the differently abled something to laugh about. He’s laughing at them. Chappelle doesn’t provoke thought; he simply provokes.

And empty provocation has a way of feeling a little selfish. It aims not to shake people into action, or push them to reconsider how they’re living their lives. It exists only to give the provocateur something to chuckle at for two seconds, and to continue deluding themselves into thinking that they have power —  to influence, to shape, to shock. They do, but egging bigots into being bigger bigots is hardly something to take pride in.

Chappelle also revisits the attack that he experienced during a show in Los Angeles, when a man who was later discovered to be carrying a knife charged him on stage. The objectively terrible incident obviously didn’t nudge Chappelle into investigating how someone could detest him so deeply. If anything, it reconfirmed his own impression of himself, that he is some kind of truth-teller out to expose the hypocrisies of civilised society; a messiah figure sent to save people from themselves. To understand why he might think like this, one needn’t look further than the show’s opening moments, in which Chappelle walks onto the stage in slow-motion, framed like a prize fighter stepping into the ring.

Story continues below this ad

Read more – Vir Das Landing review: Comedian dissects Two Indias and his two identities in sharp and sentimental Netflix standup comedy special

But for all his jokes about the trans community, Chappelle takes a centrist stance in the Will Smith- Chris Rock tussle. He says that as a Black man burdened with the responsibility of representing his community, he can relate with Smith for having cracked under years of pressure. But he can also empathise with Rock, who maintained his composure in the face of unprecedented humiliation. Chappelle brags that his was the only call that Rock took immediately after the slap — he’d seemingly been contacted by everyone from Obama to Oprah — and that the first thing he asked Rock was, “Did it hurt?” But despite having inadvertently stumbled upon the perfect set-up for a bit of introspection, Chappelle immediately does that thing where he smacks his mic on his thigh, turns around, and laughs at his own joke. There was no deeper purpose to his question; he literally just wanted to know if the slap stung. And that’s The Dreamer for you.

Dave Chappelle: The Dreamer
Director – Stan Lathan
Rating – 2.5/5

Rohan Naahar is an assistant editor at Indian Express online. He covers pop-culture across formats and mediums. He is a 'Rotten Tomatoes-approved' critic and a member of the Film Critics Guild of India. He previously worked with the Hindustan Times, where he wrote hundreds of film and television reviews, produced videos, and interviewed the biggest names in Indian and international cinema. At the Express, he writes a column titled Post Credits Scene, and has hosted a podcast called Movie Police. You can find him on X at @RohanNaahar, and write to him at rohan.naahar@indianexpress.com. He is also on LinkedIn and Instagram. ... Read More

Click here to follow Screen Digital on YouTube and stay updated with the latest from the world of cinema.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement