Woman of the Hour movie review: Anna Kendrick’s inventive serial killer thriller takes stabs in the dark
Woman of the Hour movie review: Anna Kendrick makes her directorial debut with the darkly comedic thriller, about a woman who comes face to face with a serial killer on a dating reality show. The movie is available on Lionsgate Play in India.
Anna Kendrick and Daniel Zovatto in a still from Woman of the Hour.
Sometimes, the wiser thing to do is to scale down. Not every film needs to be a sweeping epic, especially not one that demands a tight telling. Directed by the debutante Anna Kendrick, the darkly humorous thriller Woman of the Hour is based on an intriguing real-life story, but suffers from an under-confident execution. The movie would’ve worked wonderfully as a claustrophobic chamber piece, but feels compelled to jump across timelines and juggle between characters with an haphazardness that only does it harm. Kendrick is like an overeager Indian mum, checking the pressure cooker more often than she needs to, thereby releasing all the steam.
She also stars in the central role of Sheryl Bradshaw, a struggling actress who, in a moment of desperation, agrees to participate in a shady dating reality show. It’s a paid gig, she tells herself, after having blown yet another audition. Faced with the option of packing her bags and quitting Hollywood altogether, Sheryl gives herself a lifeline by signing on to appear as the object of desire on The Dating Game. Shot on the outskirts of Tinseltown, the show attracts an odd assortment of contestants and audience members. But Sheryl couldn’t care less; she wants to get through the day, collect her cash, and never look back. Little does she know that one of the three male contestants vying for her attention on the show is a serial killer.
Rodney Alcala had already murdered multiple women before he appeared on a 1978 episode of The Dating Game as a contestant. He is made to sit next to two other men with noticeably different personalities, separated from Sheryl by a barrier. Rodney has the most charming responses to Sheryl’s increasingly playful queries, and it doesn’t take him too long to have both her and the crowd eating out of his hand. This could’ve been the entire film. We could’ve remained inside the garish confines of the studio, the tension building, the exchanges getting more colourful.
But the movie has no interest in being experimental. Anna Kendrick keeps cutting back to Robert’s murders after every round — it’s like Slumdog Millionaire if it were directed by David Fincher. And every time we leave the show to witness another murder scene, or to follow a female audience member who appears to recognise Rodney, Kendrick effectively slits her own movie in the throat. Of course, there is a strong reason behind this structure. The movie wants you to develop a dislike for Rodney, which you wouldn’t have otherwise. By the time we hit murder number three, we’re meant to be shaking our fists at the screen, screaming at Sheryl to be careful of his tricks.
Played by the eerily effective Daniel Zovatto, Rodney is a textbook groomer. Later evidence showed that he also preyed on young girls, and might have killed more than 100 people before, spoiler alert, being arrested. He went on to be popularly known as The Dating Game Killer, and remains an object of tremendous interest in the sort of communities where people like him are studied. But Woman of the Hour doesn’t really examine him psychologically. Rodney appears to enjoy toying with his prey, and in the film’s admittedly harrowing opening scene, strangles an unsuspecting woman before reviving her, and then throttling her again.
Anna Kendrick has fashioned what could’ve been a formulaic serial killer movie into something of a female empowerment story, although it’s debatable if it qualifies as one. It might have one scene of violence against women too many. Her performance as Sheryl, unsurprisingly, is superior to her command over filmmaking tone. Kendrick instills in the character the same neurotic energy that she brought to her breakout role as Jessica in the Twilight movies. She has, of course, evolved tremendously since then. Woman in the Hour also works as a Substance-like showbiz satire, with the hilarious Tony Hale appearing as the obnoxious host of the reality show. But the film’s observations about both sexism and survival are rather superficial, and that’s a crying shame.
Woman of the Hour Director – Anna Kendrick Cast – Anna Kendrick, Daniel Zovatto, Tony Hale Rating – 2.5/5
Rohan Naahar is an assistant editor at Indian Express online. He covers pop-culture across formats and mediums. He is a 'Rotten Tomatoes-approved' critic and a member of the Film Critics Guild of India. He previously worked with the Hindustan Times, where he wrote hundreds of film and television reviews, produced videos, and interviewed the biggest names in Indian and international cinema. At the Express, he writes a column titled Post Credits Scene, and has hosted a podcast called Movie Police.
You can find him on X at @RohanNaahar, and write to him at rohan.naahar@indianexpress.com. He is also on LinkedIn and Instagram. ... Read More