Premium
This is an archive article published on April 21, 2023

Neelavelicham movie review: A well-executed adaptation that doesn’t justify its redundant existence

Neelavelicham review: Neelavelicham is technically a superlative movie, but director Aashiq Abu fails to convince us that this second adaptation was worth doing.

Rating: 2.5 out of 5
Neelavelicham reviewNeelavelicham has hit theatres across India.
Listen to this article
Neelavelicham movie review: A well-executed adaptation that doesn’t justify its redundant existence
x
00:00
1x 1.5x 1.8x

Some stories never die. They might change. Their morals might become obsolete, but they will be around in one form or the other. But a few stories stay intact and survive the test of time despite their redundancy and truisms. There’s an allure to these stories that go beyond their utility value and relevance. That’s why Hollywood revisited Manderley in 2020, and that could be why Aashiq Abu has gone back to Bhargavi Nilayam. Unfortunately, like the new iteration of Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca (2020), Neelavelicham, the new adaptation of Malayalam writer Vaikom Muhammad Basheer’s classic short story of the same name, doesn’t do much other than remind the current generation of the existence of such a classic story.

The ambition to get closer to the imagination of Vaikom Muhammad Basheer with advanced technology is indeed a great idea. However, Girish Gangadharan’s beautiful camera work, which offers brilliant frames every minute of the film and visual effects that brought to life the ‘blue light’ imagined by Basheer, isn’t good enough to warrant a new remake. Bhargavi Nilayam, though based on the short story, had its interpretation of Basheer’s work. It turned a mystical and philosophical text into a mainstream horror film. However, Aashiq Abu doesn’t offer any such new interpretation. Instead, Neelavelicham just ends up becoming a rich, colourful, and frame-to-frame remake of Bhargavi Nilayam.

That’s the reason the new film looks dated in terms of both story and emotions. Both the original short story and Bhargavi Nilayam have inspired horror films for generations. Naturally, one can’t expect the novelty in the latest version, which ends up becoming predictable. On top of that, being faithful to Bhargavi Nilayam has also rendered the latest film melodramatic. The love story between Bhargavi and Sasikumar, which is absent in the original short story, needed an update for the current times though the film is a period drama. Instead of reflecting the sacred position love enjoyed back in the day, the film ends up emulating the melodrama of Bharagavi Nilayam. And hence, Neelavelicham becomes a Xerox of a Xerox lacking a unique life and meaning on its own. Perhaps, the weakest element of Neelavelicham is its one-dimensional and cliched antagonist, Nanukutty (Shine Tom Chacko). The actor is not the problem here, it is the way the character is written (or should I say copy-pasted from the old film).

Yet, it is the performance of Tovino Thomas and the affectionate intonation in his dialogues with the ghost that makes the film a bit interesting. Whenever he calls her ‘Bhargavikutty’, it is heartwarming. The way he slowly starts cohabiting in the mansion with the ghost is strangely lovely to see. The interactions between the living and the dead throughout the first half become the memorable parts of the film, and that’s why the movie fizzles out post the interval, where such interactions become nil. Maybe, these few streaks of goodness might make people revisit the original text. Maybe, that’s why such echoes and Xerox copies are needed and justified.

Kirubhakar Purushothaman is a Principal Correspondent with Indian Express and is based out of Chennai. He has been writing about Tamil cinema and a bit about OTT content for the past eight years across top media houses. Like many, he is also an engineer-turned-journalist from Tamil Nadu, who chose the profession just because he wanted to make cinema a part of his professional life.   ... Read More

Click here to follow Screen Digital on YouTube and stay updated with the latest from the world of cinema.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement