This is an archive article published on April 9, 2015
MBA aspirant files PIL for re-exam, alleges errors, malpractices
Bhagat Makhijani (25) has also alleged that the method adopted by Directorate of Technical Education for evaluation of marks is erroneous.
Written by Aamir Khan
Mumbai | Updated: April 9, 2015 01:05 AM IST
3 min read
Whatsapp
twitter
Facebook
Reddit
Bhagat told the Bombay High Court through a public interest litigation (PIL) that 60,000-odd students like him faced several glitches during the exam.
A student who appeared for the state-conducted online MBA entrance exam in mid-March told the Bombay High Court Wednesday through a public interest litigation (PIL) that 60,000-odd students like him faced several glitches during the exam, including “unlike MBA-level” like spelling “cabbage” and finding the square of (a+b).
Seeking a re-test, Bhagat Makhijani (25), who lives in Bandra (west), has also alleged that the method adopted by the Directorate of Technical Education (DTE) for evaluation of marks is erroneous. Though the issue was brought to the notice of DTE director Dr Subhash Mahajan, the students’ grievances were not entertained, he has said.
Following complaints of wrong questions, the DTE on March 19 had decided to eliminate all wrong questions from the marking scheme for the question papers in all four slots conducted on March 14 and 15.
[related-post]
Makhijani, however, claims students wasted their time while attempting erroneous questions after being asked by invigilators who turned up 45 minutes late in examination centres.
The PIL also points that there was no proper seating arrangement in examination centres and candidates were allowed to sit anywhere they wished. Invigilators did not “bother” to check hall tickets or ID proofs of candidates, it adds.
“Many candidates were found referring to digital documents and using social networking apps in order to answer the questions on their cellphones… There wasn’t any provision made for partition between two adjacent computers of candidates. Almost all online examinations conducted in India and worldwide – GRE, Common Admission Test (CAT) for IIMs, CMAT conducted by AICTE, GMAT conducted by ETS) – have this kind of arrangement. This encouraged malpractices and copying,” the PIL reads.
Makhijani has also claimed that the authorities had not acted until the students threatened to go an on hunger strike.
Story continues below this ad
He says it is necessary to either have a re-examination without any discrepancies or the evaluation process be improved to give “justice” to students.
Dr Mahajan, while speaking to Newsline, ruled out the possibility of a re-test. “We cannot conduct the re-exam and will file an affidavit on our stand in the court. We are not committing anything,” he said. The case will come up for hearing on Thursday.
Aamir Khan is the Head-Legal Project for Indian Express Digital, based in New Delhi. With over 14 years of professional experience, Aamir's background as a legal professional and a veteran journalist allows him to bridge the gap between complex judicial proceedings and public understanding.
Expertise
Specialized Legal Authority: Aamir holds an LLB from CCS University, providing him with the formal legal training necessary to analyze constitutional matters, statutes, and judicial precedents with technical accuracy.
Experience
Press Trust of India (PTI): Served as News Editor, where he exercised final editorial judgment on legal stories emerging from the Supreme Court of India and various High Courts for the nation's primary news wire.
Bar and Bench: As Associate Editor, he led the vanguard of long-form legal journalism, conducting exclusive interviews and producing deep-dive investigative series on the most pressing legal issues of the day.
Foundational Reporting: His expertise is built on years of "boots-on-the-ground" reporting for The Indian Express (Print) and The Times of India, covering the legal beats in the high-intensity hubs of Mumbai and Delhi.
Multidisciplinary Academic Background: * LLB, CCS University.
PG Diploma in Journalism (New Media), Asian College of Journalism (ACJ), Chennai.
BSc in Life Sciences and Chemistry, Christ College, Bangalore—an asset for reporting on environmental law, patent litigation, and forensic evidence. ... Read More