Cannot tell a filmmaker to delete this, delete that: HC

The remarks were made after Central government counsel Gaurav Sarin told the court that comments made in the documentary, Textures of Loss, could “incite a law and order situation”. Sarin, in his arguments, also stated that the government apprehended a “powder keg” situation in Kashmir and “a security threat or violence” if the documentary was allowed to be aired without cuts. He further argued that the board had only recommended a five-second cut in the documentary — which is over one-hour long — and said this was a “reasonable restriction” under Article 19(2) of the Constitution.

[related-post]

Senior advocate Colin Gonsalves, appearing for Butalia, had argued that the proposed cuts violated the filmmaker’s freedom of speech and expression.

The cuts proposed by the CBFC include parts of comments made during interviews of the father of a child killed during the 2010 stone-pelting episode in Srinagar, and the wife of a man arrested on allegations of being a militant.

Butalia, who had based his documentary on the Kashmir Valley region between 2005-2013, had approached the High Court in January this year against the cuts.

The CBFC had asked Butalia to cut three scenes from the documentary and insert a disclaimer that the views expressed in the film by individuals were solely their views.

Curated For You

Bondi Beach attacker was from Hyderabad, left India 27 years ago

Dhurandhar Box Office Collection Day 12: Nineteen box office records broken by Ranveer Singh film as its crosses Rs 600 mark worldwide

CAT 2025 Final Answer Key to be released today; 187 objections filed, one accepted from QA section