Journalism of Courage
Advertisement
Premium

High court orders attachment of Himachal Bhawan in Delhi over unpaid dues, BJP says Sukhu govt fails to protect state’s properties

The Himachal Pradesh High Court also ordered an inquiry to identify officials responsible for failing to deposit the arbitration award due to be paid to Seli Hydro Electric Power Company.

HimachalThe Himachal High Court noted the petitioner “failed to verify the accuracy of these claims or conduct before addressing a letter to the Chief Justice on May 13, 2024”.(Express Photo)

The Himachal Pradesh High Court on Monday ordered the attachment of Himachal Bhawan, the state’s premier guesthouse at 27 Sikandra Road in New Delhi, for potential auction over unpaid dues to Seli Hydro Electric Power Company.

Justice Ajay Mohan Goel directed the principal secretary of the multi-purpose projects and power departments to conduct a factual inquiry to identify which specific officer(s) were responsible for failing to deposit the arbitration award amount of Rs 64 crore along with seven per cent interest in court.

The court emphasised that determining accountability was essential, as the interest amount would be recovered personally from the guilty officers and employees. The court ordered that the inquiry be completed within 15 days and that the report be submitted during the next hearing, scheduled for December 6.

The two-page order stated, “Therefore, for the purpose of executing the award in question, this court orders the attachment of Himachal Bhawan, 27 Sikandra Road, Mandi House, New Delhi, and the execution petitioner may take appropriate steps for its auction.”

Advocates Viplav Sharma and Anirudh Sharma represented petitioner Seli Hydro Electric Power Company, while Additional Advocate General Pushpender Jaswal appeared on behalf of Himachal Pradesh.

Arbitration after power project fails to kick off

In 2009, the Himachal Pradesh government allotted a 320 MW power project to Seli Hydro Company in the Lahaul and Spiti district. The Border Roads Organisation was deployed to assist with the required road construction. According to the agreement, the state government was to provide basic facilities for the hydro company to start the project on time, but this did not occur.

As a result, the company filed a writ petition in the high court in 2017. The company’s lawyer argued that the lack of facilities forced the company to abandon the project and return it to the government. Subsequently, the government seized the upfront premium.

Story continues below this ad

After hearing both parties, the court on January 13, 2023, ordered the government to return the Rs 64 crore upfront premium to the company. However, the government filed a letters patent appeal (an appeal made to another bench in the same high court against a decision made by a single judge).

However, a division bench stayed the order, conditional upon the respondents depositing the arbitration amount in court. When the respondents failed to deposit the amount, the division bench lifted the stay on July 15, 2024, upholding the single-judge bench’s decision.

Considering these facts, the court stated that since no interim order favoured the state, implementing the arbitration award was essential. The court said the government delayed depositing the award amount was accruing daily interest, which must be paid from the public treasury.

BJP blames Congress govt

Opposition BJP leaders, including Leader of Opposition (LoP) and former chief minister Jairam Thakur, criticised the Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu-led Congress government, accusing it of failing to protect the interests and property of Himachal Pradesh.

Story continues below this ad

Opposition leaders also questioned the efficiency of the state’s law department, alleging that it failed to effectively present Himachal Pradesh’s case in court. Thakur said, “It is a sorry state of affairs in Himachal Pradesh. The government has failed to protect the interests of the people of our state. Himachal Bhawan in Delhi is the pride of every Himachali. The Himachal Bhawan in Delhi is another home for every person in the state who goes to the national capital. I fear that if the situation continues, our state secretariat, Vidhan Sabha building, etc., in Shimla will also be attached by the courts in various matters in the coming days.”

Speaking to reporters in Shimla on Tuesday, Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu said he had not yet reviewed the high court order, “The upfront premium is governed by a policy… In 2006, when the energy policy was formed, I was one of the architects of this policy…”

He added, “We had set a reserve price per megawatt on which companies bid. Arbitration decided the matter of the upfront premium, and our government challenged the arbitration order in the high court. As per the order, the government had to deposit Rs 64 crore as part of the Arbitration.”

Saurabh Parashar is a journalist with The Indian Express, where he primarily covers developments in Himachal Pradesh. He has been associated with The Indian Express since 2017 and has earlier worked with The Times of India. He has 17 year + experience in the field of print journalism. An alumnus of Government College for Men, Sector 11, (Panjab University), Chandigarh, Saurabh holds a Diploma in Journalism from Bhartiya Vidya Bhawan, Chandigarh. He pursued his Master’s in Mass Communication from Guru Jambheshwar University of Science & Technology, Hisar. In addition, he completed his law degree from Himachal Pradesh University (HPU), Shimla. ... Read More

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Tags:
  • Himachal Bhawan
Edition
Install the Express App for
a better experience
Featured
Trending Topics
News
Multimedia
Follow Us
Subscribe to ExpressClick here to get monthly subscription plan of Indian Express
X