It certainly looked like the same Libyan leader,even if he was clad in a black robe rather than brown,and he had swapped his black lapel pin of the African continent for a green one. But the low-key,almost contemplative Col Muammar Gaddafi who turned up at the Council on Foreign Relations on Thursday had nothing to do with the flamboyant,discursive provocateur who riveted,offended and finally exhausted the United Nations General Assembly a day earlier.
For an hour,Gaddafi offered polite answers to polite questions from an audience of New York financiers,business people,academics and a few journalists,in a conversation that ranged from the roots of Islamic terrorism to Libyas desire for better relations with the West.
It is in our interest for Libya to have good relations with the US, Gaddafi said through an interpreter,speaking Arabic in a low monotone that barely registered above a whisper.
There was no mention of prosecuting those responsible for the mass murder in Iraq,as he had demanded at the General Assembly. No call for an investigation of the assassinations of John F Kennedy and the Martin Luther King Jr No pawing through a pile of scrawled notes or waving of the UN charter.
If the standing-room-only crowd had turned up for another display of geopolitical performance arts,they were sorely disappointed.
Yesterday was theater; today was a give-and-take, said the councils president,Richard N Haass,who looked pleasantly surprised to have presided over a seminar rather than a circus. You might disagree with him,but there is no question it was a legitimate debate.
After 40 years as Leader and Guide of the Revolution,Gaddafi has worked to shed his outlaw status,relinquishing his nuclear and chemical-weapons programmes,becoming chairman of the African Union and seeking foreign investment.
In his first appearance at the UN,he followed a tradition of grandstanding,from Nikita Khrushchev,who brandished his shoe,to Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez,who in 2006 said he smelled sulfur on the rostrum the day after President George W Bush spoke. But with an influential American audience and the cameras turned off,the softer strongman came out.