Premium
This is an archive article published on May 27, 2005

Wah English!

• So English is why India is developing (‘In praise of Thomas ...

.

So English is why India is developing (‘In praise of Thomas Macaulay’, IE, May 26). Wah bhai wah! So why is Liberia not developing as the people there speak mostly English and have forgotten their African heritage? Why did Japan develop even though the Japanese don’t use English? English is a source of our poverty, illiteracy and slavery, not of our modernity.

Shabu Adelaide

I think in English, but regret that fact. Native language ability develops greater strategic abilities to negotiate the world as seen with the Chinese, Koreans, Taiwanese, Japanese etc. This comes from the ability to realise one’s place in the world. We Indians don’t have it.

S. Manohar On e-mail

It’s Saltoro

Pranab Dhal Samanta, like other Indian journalists, refers to the area under dispute in Jammu and Kashmir as Siachen (‘On the table for Siachen talks: freeze on troops, thaw in chill’, IE, May 25). Siachen glacier has been fully under the Indian army’s control for years; the de facto Indo-Pak troops standoff is to the west of the glacier in Saltoro Ridge area. Therefore, the talks should be correctly termed Saltoro talks.

Arun Khanna Indianapolis

A good person

Story continues below this ad

My family and I were shocked when we heard that Sunil Dutt is no more with us. Dutt saab was a very good person and very hard working. Whether in Bollywood or in politics, he took care of his duties and responsibilities. India has lost a very good person and no one can take his place.

Paramjeet S. Ajmani Pune

Research is key

This refers to Deepak Nayyar’s ‘Universities in the sick bay’ (IE, May 25). I have taught at both Indian and western universities. The major difference is that in the west, a university vice-chancellor, a head of the department and every university teacher is judged on the basis of the continuing research output of the individual.

A.K. Aggarwal Ahmedabad

I was once invited by the CSIR through the TOKTEN scheme (Transfer of know how through expatriate nationals) of the UN, and was surprised to see the minimal impact that research institutions have on university education, and therefore on the people that ultimately get into those institutions. Teaching and research must go hand in hand, one stimulates the other. Also, as Nayyar has correctly pointed out, the lack of reward and penalty for performance and non-performance, respectively, is a great hindrance to progress.

Jibamitra Ganguly On e-mail

Bofors tales

V. Gangadhar’s ‘O Cinderella’ (IE, May 24) brings to mind my daughter’s complaint, ‘‘other children are brought up on Cinderella; we were brought up on Bofors!’’

Mani Shankar Aiyar On e-mail

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement