Turbulence in A-I over bills
Air India officials are seeing red over excess billing by its law firm. Its official law firm, M.V. Kini and Co, has charged the airline Rs ...

Air India officials are seeing red over excess billing by its law firm. Its official law firm, M.V. Kini and Co, has charged the airline Rs 1.43 lakh for caveats filed during the pilots’ strike last year.
The caveat is an advance notice to the court to ensure that a matter is not heard in the absence of the person who sent it. It has a stipulated format and one has to simply fill in the name and address of the opposite party, file it in the court registry, and send a copy to the intending petitioners.
And for this work, the Mumbai-based firm slapped a bill of Rs 1.43 lakh on Air India, on April 29, 2003.
Sources say A-I has a full-fledged legal department with qualified law officers earning fat salaries who can handle legal work. But wasteful legal expenditure with kickbacks is the norm. A total of 87 caveats were filed in the Bombay High Court and in the City Civil Court. Kini and Co. says the bill covers its ‘‘professional charges for drafting, filing, settling and finalising’’ caveats against 29 parties at the rate of Rs 1,500 each.
General manager (legal) T.N. Kumar and senior manager (finance) Milan Shah disagree. The airline cannot pay the bill, they say, as caveats are not included in the schedule of fees that’s part of the contract with the law firm.
The officers agree that the caveats were probably filed anticipating that the Indian Pilots’ Guild would seek an injunction. But filing caveats is mere clerical work, they say.
Photos




- 01
- 02
- 03
- 04
- 05