Truncated route

As the date for the arrival of the Olympic torch approaches, China’s nervousness over the Tibetan protests will increase.

• Your editorial, ‘The 3 km leash’ is timely. As the date for the arrival of the Olympic torch approaches, China’s nervousness over the Tibetan protests will increase. In demanding that the route of the torch be restricted to less than one-tenth of the original in Delhi, the Chinese nervousness has already shown.

Ever since the Tibetan protests and violence have erupted, the Indian government has been exhibiting extra deference to our neighbour’s susceptibilities. This is regrettable, given that the Chinese government summoned our ambassador in Beijing at 2 am, and then called the venerable Dalai Lama “a serial liar” and ignored his commitment to Tibet’s autonomous character within the fold of China. While China can afford to be ignorant of the nuances of democracy, India cannot continue to bow to every wish of its big neighbour.

— Prasad Malladi

Nidadavole

Chinese masters

• You have rightly castigated the UPA government for its decision to cut the Olympic torch route so as to please its Left allies and their Chinese masters. “Call this independent foreign policy?” the editorial asks. Is it not yet another example of a weak-kneed government undermining itself?

Story continues below this ad

When the capital’s security apparatus can ensure a huge Republic Day parade for many kilometres, can’t the regional super power secure the 33 km route of the Olympic torch? How can the possibility of the threat of peaceful protest by some Tibetans, a legitimate activity in a democracy, cause such a major change?

One can understand an authoritarian regime’s hypersensitivity to a peaceful protest, but why should a regime headed by the Congress, a party whose chief weapon during the freedom struggle was satyagraha, buckle like this? Why bend backwards to an aggressive, arrogant neighbour that doesn’t care about our sensitivities?

— M. Ratan

New Delhi

Democracy test

• In ‘The Obama effect’ Pratap Bhanu Mehta points out that a genuine leadership in a democracy should seek to inculcate reason and reciprocity. He aptly observes: “Our politicians are interested more in opportunistically using the currency of indignity and oppression than in overcoming it… The very simplistic manner in which they have dealt with the burden of caste has, in turn, produced a corrosive scepticism that makes any constructive conversation about caste impossible.” Whether we are a genuine democracy is debatable.

— M.C. Joshi

Lucknow

Suns of the soil

• Bal Thackeray must not miss the point that, in Tamil Nadu politics and Tamil movies, stars are more than closely linked (‘Role reversals’). The public man and the film star are not separate entities. Karmabhoomi and janmabhoomi have nothing to do with it. What is the contribution of the Shiv Sena to the karmabhoomi?

Story continues below this ad

Collecting contributions, which they may well be using to their personal ends?

— M. Shrinivasa Kamath

Bangalore

Canada, UK and Australia formally recognise a Palestinian state

World42 min ago

The UK, Canada, and Australia have recognized Palestine as a state, going against the US and Israel's opposition. British PM Starmer aims to revive peace without Hamas and hostage release. Canada and Australia also recognize Palestine, condemning terrorism. Over 145 UN members recognize Palestine, with France likely to join soon.

View all shorts

Live Blog