Premium
This is an archive article published on October 5, 2007

Letters to the editor

The counter-view often has an appeal that goes beyond conventional argument...

.

The counter-view often has an appeal that goes beyond conventional arguments. At a point when almost the whole world — and indeed this newspaper — had argued against the military junta in Myanmar, Chital-based Natranjan A. Wala’s letter piped another tune. It wins this week’s award.

AS a person who has travelled to Myanmar (Burma’s old name), I must say that I did not find half-naked, half-starved children and beggars like those in Indian towns. The roads are metalled and not tarred but neat and clean. There were few petrol-driven vehicles, perhaps to conserve petrol. The Western imperialists have denied petrol products to Myanmar, as it does not fall in line with their diktat. Second, Myanmar’s rulers have ensured that they do not borrow from Western moneylenders unlike India, which is under a debt burden of billions of dollars. Lastly, Western powers are sore that there are no Christian conversions in Myanmar unlike in India. Its government has sent the Christian Karen rebels packing to the Philippines. Regarding Madame Aung San Suu Kyi, her father Aung San was trained by the Japanese and made a general by them. But when the tide of the war turned in favour of the British, he deserted his comrades and joined the Brits, who made him the president of Burma. Some his old comrades subsequently killed him. As for his daughter, Suu Kyi, she married a Briton, and received a huge amount of Western money to topple the regime. What can you expect of such a family?

TN as Anna wanted

The history of Tamil Nadu in the piece, ‘Sea change in DMK’ (IE, October 3), was flawed. EVR was the treasurer of the TN Congress when Rajaji was the TNCC president. There were charges of some money being not accounted for, and Rajaji asked EVR for accounts. EVR got angry, left the party and joined the Justice Party, which was already carrying on an anti-brahmin movement. The stalwarts of that party like A. Ramaswamy Mudaliar and P.T. Rajan were men of absolute integrity, like any Congressman of those days. They were also staunchly religious. EVR could not find a place he thought he deserved in the party and therefore left the Justice Party too and started the atheist Dravida Kazhagam. EVR did have some success in fighting against the caste system but it was the late C.N. Annadurai who gave real life to that movement through his intellectually stimulating speeches and writings. Anna was a statesman, not a politician, and made it clear that his fight was against brahminism, and not brahmins. He was a large-hearted man, a man of humour and was thoroughly against violence. That is how his movement gathered such a large following, even among the poor. He once said, “I see God in the smiles on the face of the poor.” Had CNA lived a little longer, the history of Tamil Nadu would have been different.

— G. Dwarakanath

Bangalore

October 2 neglect

The birthdays of Mahatma Gandhi and Lal Bahadur Shastri and Kamaraj’s remembrance day fall on one and the same day: October 2. But every year, Lal Bahadur Shastri, the little man with an enormous heart, is conspicuously overlooked, although some ritualistic garlanding of his statue may take place in Parliament. No leader takes care to celebrate his birthday as they do the birthdays of Mahatma Gandhi and Kamaraj. Shastri and Narasimha Rao are surely the best among Congress prime ministers, who raised India to great heights, but they continue to be neglected, presumably because they do not belong to the dynasty.

— V. Kameswaran

Chennai

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement